Joe Legal vs Jose Illegal

[SK in CV]

[quote=KSMountain][quote=SK in CV]Do you really think that Jose’s 8 year old son really deserves less of an education than Joe’s son simply because of where his parents were born?[/quote]

SK in CV: Meet 8 year old Juanita from Paraguay. She is very cute and bright and innocent. She smiles a lot and is very likable.

Do you really think she deserves less of an education than Joe’s son simply because of where SHE was born? How arrogant!

Why should we discriminate based on a criteria as passe as physical location? Why not educate everyone in the whole world?

We can either fly everybody here for 18 or so years or we can just send out say 200 million teachers to do it on location. That’ll give class sizes of about 30 students per teacher. Hope that’s ok with you.[/quote]

I suppose you’ve made a point here. I have no idea what it is. I think Juanita is as worthy of an education as any other child. Unfortunately, living in Paraguay, with one of the lowest literacy rates on the planet, she’s unlikely to get much of an education. Hopefully her parents will find a way to sneak her across the border so we can provide it.

(And in case you were wondering, I would have no problem with a world without borders. In theory anyway.)

[KSMountain]

[quote=SK in CV]I suppose you’ve made a point here. I have no idea what it is…

Hopefully her parents will find a way to sneak her across the border so we can provide it.

(And in case you were wondering, I would have no problem with a world without borders. In theory anyway.)[/quote]

I’m exploring the limits of your largesse with other people’s tax dollars, SK.

Isn’t Juanita also deserving of quality medical care? Why should American kids have better healthcare than Paraguayan kids? That’s certainly bigoted and unfair. Shouldn’t the taxpayers of the US provide medical care for the children of Paraguay?

Oh, but what about proper nutrition too? Isn’t that fundamental? And clean water. Of course Juanita and her peers deserve that.

But, wait. While we’re helping Paraguay, we can’t neglect Uruguay. And the Ivory Coast. And Liberia. And Bhutan. And Ghana.

Or maybe you’re right. Open borders and all, just bring them here. For the poor in countries not geographically close to us though, I think we’ll have to send planes or boats, don’t you think?

Or are you really so selfish as to limit your compassion and generosity only to folks who are physically able to get within the borders of the U.S.? Please tell me I misunderstand you.

[KSMountain]

[quote=SK in CV]I suppose you’ve made a point here. I have no idea what it is…

Hopefully her parents will find a way to sneak her across the border so we can provide it.

(And in case you were wondering, I would have no problem with a world without borders. In theory anyway.)[/quote]

I’m exploring the limits of your largesse with other people’s tax dollars, SK.

Isn’t Juanita also deserving of quality medical care? Why should American kids have better healthcare than Paraguayan kids? That’s certainly bigoted and unfair. Shouldn’t the taxpayers of the US provide medical care for the children of Paraguay?

Oh, but what about proper nutrition too? Isn’t that fundamental? And clean water. Of course Juanita and her peers deserve that.

But, wait. While we’re helping Paraguay, we can’t neglect Uruguay. And the Ivory Coast. And Liberia. And Bhutan. And Ghana.

Or maybe you’re right. Open borders and all, just bring them here. For the poor in countries not geographically close to us though, I think we’ll have to send planes or boats, don’t you think?

Or are you really so selfish as to limit your compassion and generosity only to folks who are physically able to get within the borders of the U.S.? Please tell me I misunderstand you.

[KSMountain]

[quote=SK in CV]I suppose you’ve made a point here. I have no idea what it is…

Hopefully her parents will find a way to sneak her across the border so we can provide it.

(And in case you were wondering, I would have no problem with a world without borders. In theory anyway.)[/quote]

I’m exploring the limits of your largesse with other people’s tax dollars, SK.

Isn’t Juanita also deserving of quality medical care? Why should American kids have better healthcare than Paraguayan kids? That’s certainly bigoted and unfair. Shouldn’t the taxpayers of the US provide medical care for the children of Paraguay?

Oh, but what about proper nutrition too? Isn’t that fundamental? And clean water. Of course Juanita and her peers deserve that.

But, wait. While we’re helping Paraguay, we can’t neglect Uruguay. And the Ivory Coast. And Liberia. And Bhutan. And Ghana.

Or maybe you’re right. Open borders and all, just bring them here. For the poor in countries not geographically close to us though, I think we’ll have to send planes or boats, don’t you think?

Or are you really so selfish as to limit your compassion and generosity only to folks who are physically able to get within the borders of the U.S.? Please tell me I misunderstand you.

[KSMountain]

[quote=SK in CV]I suppose you’ve made a point here. I have no idea what it is…

Hopefully her parents will find a way to sneak her across the border so we can provide it.

(And in case you were wondering, I would have no problem with a world without borders. In theory anyway.)[/quote]

I’m exploring the limits of your largesse with other people’s tax dollars, SK.

Isn’t Juanita also deserving of quality medical care? Why should American kids have better healthcare than Paraguayan kids? That’s certainly bigoted and unfair. Shouldn’t the taxpayers of the US provide medical care for the children of Paraguay?

Oh, but what about proper nutrition too? Isn’t that fundamental? And clean water. Of course Juanita and her peers deserve that.

But, wait. While we’re helping Paraguay, we can’t neglect Uruguay. And the Ivory Coast. And Liberia. And Bhutan. And Ghana.

Or maybe you’re right. Open borders and all, just bring them here. For the poor in countries not geographically close to us though, I think we’ll have to send planes or boats, don’t you think?

Or are you really so selfish as to limit your compassion and generosity only to folks who are physically able to get within the borders of the U.S.? Please tell me I misunderstand you.

[KSMountain]

[quote=SK in CV]I suppose you’ve made a point here. I have no idea what it is…

Hopefully her parents will find a way to sneak her across the border so we can provide it.

(And in case you were wondering, I would have no problem with a world without borders. In theory anyway.)[/quote]

I’m exploring the limits of your largesse with other people’s tax dollars, SK.

Isn’t Juanita also deserving of quality medical care? Why should American kids have better healthcare than Paraguayan kids? That’s certainly bigoted and unfair. Shouldn’t the taxpayers of the US provide medical care for the children of Paraguay?

Oh, but what about proper nutrition too? Isn’t that fundamental? And clean water. Of course Juanita and her peers deserve that.

But, wait. While we’re helping Paraguay, we can’t neglect Uruguay. And the Ivory Coast. And Liberia. And Bhutan. And Ghana.

Or maybe you’re right. Open borders and all, just bring them here. For the poor in countries not geographically close to us though, I think we’ll have to send planes or boats, don’t you think?

Or are you really so selfish as to limit your compassion and generosity only to folks who are physically able to get within the borders of the U.S.? Please tell me I misunderstand you.

[Anonymous]

I think SK understands that there isn’t enough to go around.

No need to be so callous about it.

[Anonymous]

I think SK understands that there isn’t enough to go around.

No need to be so callous about it.

[Anonymous]

I think SK understands that there isn’t enough to go around.

No need to be so callous about it.

[Anonymous]

I think SK understands that there isn’t enough to go around.

No need to be so callous about it.

[Anonymous]

I think SK understands that there isn’t enough to go around.

No need to be so callous about it.

[rnen]

[quote=SK in CV][quote=KSMountain][quote=SK in CV]Do you really think that Jose’s 8 year old son really deserves less of an education than Joe’s son simply because of where his parents were born?[/quote]

SK in CV: Meet 8 year old Juanita from Paraguay. She is very cute and bright and innocent. She smiles a lot and is very likable.

Do you really think she deserves less of an education than Joe’s son simply because of where SHE was born? How arrogant!

Why should we discriminate based on a criteria as passe as physical location? Why not educate everyone in the whole world?

We can either fly everybody here for 18 or so years or we can just send out say 200 million teachers to do it on location. That’ll give class sizes of about 30 students per teacher. Hope that’s ok with you.[/quote]

I suppose you’ve made a point here. I have no idea what it is. I think Juanita is as worthy of an education as any other child. Unfortunately, living in Paraguay, with one of the lowest literacy rates on the planet, she’s unlikely to get much of an education. Hopefully her parents will find a way to sneak her across the border so we can provide it.

(And in case you were wondering, I ould have no problem with a world without borders. In theory anyway.)[/quote]

I do not think anyone here would argue that she is not worthy of an education, it is how she gets it is the assue. Life is unfair and and she and millions of others have no say in where or when they are born. I encourage those that feel that everyone should have an education to donate to the many organizations that are in place just for that purpose. I do not want those same people TAKING money from my pocket to satisfy THEIR need to feel like they have done something worthy. There is a big difference between offering help to those less fortunate and having some one take from you to give to others. I donate to the Childrens Heritage Fund every month out of choice. That is how I CHOOSE to help others.

Those that feel they need to TAKE from others and force them to comply with THEIR sense of morality need to get out of others business and do what is right for them.

Personally I think that being forced to pay for the education of illegal children, the welfare of illegals who have kids here and the health care of those who are here illegally pisses me off. Those of you who feel the illegals are entitled to it PONY UP the money then relax at home with light heart knowing you have done some good in this world. Let the rest of us be charitable by means of our own choosing.

[rnen]

[quote=SK in CV][quote=KSMountain][quote=SK in CV]Do you really think that Jose’s 8 year old son really deserves less of an education than Joe’s son simply because of where his parents were born?[/quote]

SK in CV: Meet 8 year old Juanita from Paraguay. She is very cute and bright and innocent. She smiles a lot and is very likable.

Do you really think she deserves less of an education than Joe’s son simply because of where SHE was born? How arrogant!

Why should we discriminate based on a criteria as passe as physical location? Why not educate everyone in the whole world?

We can either fly everybody here for 18 or so years or we can just send out say 200 million teachers to do it on location. That’ll give class sizes of about 30 students per teacher. Hope that’s ok with you.[/quote]

I suppose you’ve made a point here. I have no idea what it is. I think Juanita is as worthy of an education as any other child. Unfortunately, living in Paraguay, with one of the lowest literacy rates on the planet, she’s unlikely to get much of an education. Hopefully her parents will find a way to sneak her across the border so we can provide it.

(And in case you were wondering, I ould have no problem with a world without borders. In theory anyway.)[/quote]

I do not think anyone here would argue that she is not worthy of an education, it is how she gets it is the assue. Life is unfair and and she and millions of others have no say in where or when they are born. I encourage those that feel that everyone should have an education to donate to the many organizations that are in place just for that purpose. I do not want those same people TAKING money from my pocket to satisfy THEIR need to feel like they have done something worthy. There is a big difference between offering help to those less fortunate and having some one take from you to give to others. I donate to the Childrens Heritage Fund every month out of choice. That is how I CHOOSE to help others.

Those that feel they need to TAKE from others and force them to comply with THEIR sense of morality need to get out of others business and do what is right for them.

Personally I think that being forced to pay for the education of illegal children, the welfare of illegals who have kids here and the health care of those who are here illegally pisses me off. Those of you who feel the illegals are entitled to it PONY UP the money then relax at home with light heart knowing you have done some good in this world. Let the rest of us be charitable by means of our own choosing.

[rnen]

[quote=SK in CV][quote=KSMountain][quote=SK in CV]Do you really think that Jose’s 8 year old son really deserves less of an education than Joe’s son simply because of where his parents were born?[/quote]

SK in CV: Meet 8 year old Juanita from Paraguay. She is very cute and bright and innocent. She smiles a lot and is very likable.

Do you really think she deserves less of an education than Joe’s son simply because of where SHE was born? How arrogant!

Why should we discriminate based on a criteria as passe as physical location? Why not educate everyone in the whole world?

We can either fly everybody here for 18 or so years or we can just send out say 200 million teachers to do it on location. That’ll give class sizes of about 30 students per teacher. Hope that’s ok with you.[/quote]

I suppose you’ve made a point here. I have no idea what it is. I think Juanita is as worthy of an education as any other child. Unfortunately, living in Paraguay, with one of the lowest literacy rates on the planet, she’s unlikely to get much of an education. Hopefully her parents will find a way to sneak her across the border so we can provide it.

(And in case you were wondering, I ould have no problem with a world without borders. In theory anyway.)[/quote]

I do not think anyone here would argue that she is not worthy of an education, it is how she gets it is the assue. Life is unfair and and she and millions of others have no say in where or when they are born. I encourage those that feel that everyone should have an education to donate to the many organizations that are in place just for that purpose. I do not want those same people TAKING money from my pocket to satisfy THEIR need to feel like they have done something worthy. There is a big difference between offering help to those less fortunate and having some one take from you to give to others. I donate to the Childrens Heritage Fund every month out of choice. That is how I CHOOSE to help others.

Those that feel they need to TAKE from others and force them to comply with THEIR sense of morality need to get out of others business and do what is right for them.

Personally I think that being forced to pay for the education of illegal children, the welfare of illegals who have kids here and the health care of those who are here illegally pisses me off. Those of you who feel the illegals are entitled to it PONY UP the money then relax at home with light heart knowing you have done some good in this world. Let the rest of us be charitable by means of our own choosing.

[rnen]

[quote=SK in CV][quote=KSMountain][quote=SK in CV]Do you really think that Jose’s 8 year old son really deserves less of an education than Joe’s son simply because of where his parents were born?[/quote]

SK in CV: Meet 8 year old Juanita from Paraguay. She is very cute and bright and innocent. She smiles a lot and is very likable.

Do you really think she deserves less of an education than Joe’s son simply because of where SHE was born? How arrogant!

Why should we discriminate based on a criteria as passe as physical location? Why not educate everyone in the whole world?

We can either fly everybody here for 18 or so years or we can just send out say 200 million teachers to do it on location. That’ll give class sizes of about 30 students per teacher. Hope that’s ok with you.[/quote]

I suppose you’ve made a point here. I have no idea what it is. I think Juanita is as worthy of an education as any other child. Unfortunately, living in Paraguay, with one of the lowest literacy rates on the planet, she’s unlikely to get much of an education. Hopefully her parents will find a way to sneak her across the border so we can provide it.

(And in case you were wondering, I ould have no problem with a world without borders. In theory anyway.)[/quote]

I do not think anyone here would argue that she is not worthy of an education, it is how she gets it is the assue. Life is unfair and and she and millions of others have no say in where or when they are born. I encourage those that feel that everyone should have an education to donate to the many organizations that are in place just for that purpose. I do not want those same people TAKING money from my pocket to satisfy THEIR need to feel like they have done something worthy. There is a big difference between offering help to those less fortunate and having some one take from you to give to others. I donate to the Childrens Heritage Fund every month out of choice. That is how I CHOOSE to help others.

Those that feel they need to TAKE from others and force them to comply with THEIR sense of morality need to get out of others business and do what is right for them.

Personally I think that being forced to pay for the education of illegal children, the welfare of illegals who have kids here and the health care of those who are here illegally pisses me off. Those of you who feel the illegals are entitled to it PONY UP the money then relax at home with light heart knowing you have done some good in this world. Let the rest of us be charitable by means of our own choosing.

[Author]

Posts