- This topic has 490 replies, 27 voices, and was last updated 14 years, 2 months ago by
weberlin.
-
AuthorPosts
-
May 7, 2010 at 10:16 AM #548538May 7, 2010 at 10:31 AM #547583
afx114
ParticipantI’ve posted this before, but the whole “learn English or don’t come here” thing is bunk. It generally takes at least 2 generations for complete assimilation. This is true for any nation and any language, and has been true for every prior wave of immigrants – Irish, Italian, etc…
1) Immigrant: Speaks native tongue, picks up the local language enough to get by.
2) 2nd generation: Immigrant’s children grow up immersed in the local language and hear it from childhood. Their friends speaks the local language and their schools teach it. Sure, they speak their native tongue at home, only because it’s the optimal way to converse with family who only know the native tongue.
3) By the 3rd generation, the original language is mostly lost, as they prefer to speak the local language.This is true not only with language but also with other cultural heritage – food, religion, beliefs, morals. I’ve seen this in every Mexican immigrant family I know. And I know a lot. Grandma speaks Spanish, Mom speaks both, and the kids all think Spanish is for the old people. This is how it would work for you and your family if you moved to Japan or Germany or Iran.
This is America — speak whatever the fuck language you want.
May 7, 2010 at 10:31 AM #547694afx114
ParticipantI’ve posted this before, but the whole “learn English or don’t come here” thing is bunk. It generally takes at least 2 generations for complete assimilation. This is true for any nation and any language, and has been true for every prior wave of immigrants – Irish, Italian, etc…
1) Immigrant: Speaks native tongue, picks up the local language enough to get by.
2) 2nd generation: Immigrant’s children grow up immersed in the local language and hear it from childhood. Their friends speaks the local language and their schools teach it. Sure, they speak their native tongue at home, only because it’s the optimal way to converse with family who only know the native tongue.
3) By the 3rd generation, the original language is mostly lost, as they prefer to speak the local language.This is true not only with language but also with other cultural heritage – food, religion, beliefs, morals. I’ve seen this in every Mexican immigrant family I know. And I know a lot. Grandma speaks Spanish, Mom speaks both, and the kids all think Spanish is for the old people. This is how it would work for you and your family if you moved to Japan or Germany or Iran.
This is America — speak whatever the fuck language you want.
May 7, 2010 at 10:31 AM #548177afx114
ParticipantI’ve posted this before, but the whole “learn English or don’t come here” thing is bunk. It generally takes at least 2 generations for complete assimilation. This is true for any nation and any language, and has been true for every prior wave of immigrants – Irish, Italian, etc…
1) Immigrant: Speaks native tongue, picks up the local language enough to get by.
2) 2nd generation: Immigrant’s children grow up immersed in the local language and hear it from childhood. Their friends speaks the local language and their schools teach it. Sure, they speak their native tongue at home, only because it’s the optimal way to converse with family who only know the native tongue.
3) By the 3rd generation, the original language is mostly lost, as they prefer to speak the local language.This is true not only with language but also with other cultural heritage – food, religion, beliefs, morals. I’ve seen this in every Mexican immigrant family I know. And I know a lot. Grandma speaks Spanish, Mom speaks both, and the kids all think Spanish is for the old people. This is how it would work for you and your family if you moved to Japan or Germany or Iran.
This is America — speak whatever the fuck language you want.
May 7, 2010 at 10:31 AM #548275afx114
ParticipantI’ve posted this before, but the whole “learn English or don’t come here” thing is bunk. It generally takes at least 2 generations for complete assimilation. This is true for any nation and any language, and has been true for every prior wave of immigrants – Irish, Italian, etc…
1) Immigrant: Speaks native tongue, picks up the local language enough to get by.
2) 2nd generation: Immigrant’s children grow up immersed in the local language and hear it from childhood. Their friends speaks the local language and their schools teach it. Sure, they speak their native tongue at home, only because it’s the optimal way to converse with family who only know the native tongue.
3) By the 3rd generation, the original language is mostly lost, as they prefer to speak the local language.This is true not only with language but also with other cultural heritage – food, religion, beliefs, morals. I’ve seen this in every Mexican immigrant family I know. And I know a lot. Grandma speaks Spanish, Mom speaks both, and the kids all think Spanish is for the old people. This is how it would work for you and your family if you moved to Japan or Germany or Iran.
This is America — speak whatever the fuck language you want.
May 7, 2010 at 10:31 AM #548548afx114
ParticipantI’ve posted this before, but the whole “learn English or don’t come here” thing is bunk. It generally takes at least 2 generations for complete assimilation. This is true for any nation and any language, and has been true for every prior wave of immigrants – Irish, Italian, etc…
1) Immigrant: Speaks native tongue, picks up the local language enough to get by.
2) 2nd generation: Immigrant’s children grow up immersed in the local language and hear it from childhood. Their friends speaks the local language and their schools teach it. Sure, they speak their native tongue at home, only because it’s the optimal way to converse with family who only know the native tongue.
3) By the 3rd generation, the original language is mostly lost, as they prefer to speak the local language.This is true not only with language but also with other cultural heritage – food, religion, beliefs, morals. I’ve seen this in every Mexican immigrant family I know. And I know a lot. Grandma speaks Spanish, Mom speaks both, and the kids all think Spanish is for the old people. This is how it would work for you and your family if you moved to Japan or Germany or Iran.
This is America — speak whatever the fuck language you want.
May 7, 2010 at 10:44 AM #547593briansd1
Guestafx114, I’ve observed the same thing. You just have to get invited to a family party where there are 3 or 4 generations present.
The insecurity comes from the people who don’t understand what the newcomers are talking about. They feel like they are losing “their” California and “their” San Diego.
Things change. You have the choice of embracing change or forever feel bitter about it.
May 7, 2010 at 10:44 AM #547704briansd1
Guestafx114, I’ve observed the same thing. You just have to get invited to a family party where there are 3 or 4 generations present.
The insecurity comes from the people who don’t understand what the newcomers are talking about. They feel like they are losing “their” California and “their” San Diego.
Things change. You have the choice of embracing change or forever feel bitter about it.
May 7, 2010 at 10:44 AM #548187briansd1
Guestafx114, I’ve observed the same thing. You just have to get invited to a family party where there are 3 or 4 generations present.
The insecurity comes from the people who don’t understand what the newcomers are talking about. They feel like they are losing “their” California and “their” San Diego.
Things change. You have the choice of embracing change or forever feel bitter about it.
May 7, 2010 at 10:44 AM #548285briansd1
Guestafx114, I’ve observed the same thing. You just have to get invited to a family party where there are 3 or 4 generations present.
The insecurity comes from the people who don’t understand what the newcomers are talking about. They feel like they are losing “their” California and “their” San Diego.
Things change. You have the choice of embracing change or forever feel bitter about it.
May 7, 2010 at 10:44 AM #548558briansd1
Guestafx114, I’ve observed the same thing. You just have to get invited to a family party where there are 3 or 4 generations present.
The insecurity comes from the people who don’t understand what the newcomers are talking about. They feel like they are losing “their” California and “their” San Diego.
Things change. You have the choice of embracing change or forever feel bitter about it.
May 7, 2010 at 10:48 AM #547598meadandale
Participant[quote=briansd1]
Anyway, when I was little I complained that my brother got a gift and I didn’t. My dad told me to worry about what I have, not what others are getting.[/quote]This is a straw man…
Your dad didn’t take money from YOUR piggy bank to buy your brother the gift.
May 7, 2010 at 10:48 AM #547709meadandale
Participant[quote=briansd1]
Anyway, when I was little I complained that my brother got a gift and I didn’t. My dad told me to worry about what I have, not what others are getting.[/quote]This is a straw man…
Your dad didn’t take money from YOUR piggy bank to buy your brother the gift.
May 7, 2010 at 10:48 AM #548192meadandale
Participant[quote=briansd1]
Anyway, when I was little I complained that my brother got a gift and I didn’t. My dad told me to worry about what I have, not what others are getting.[/quote]This is a straw man…
Your dad didn’t take money from YOUR piggy bank to buy your brother the gift.
May 7, 2010 at 10:48 AM #548290meadandale
Participant[quote=briansd1]
Anyway, when I was little I complained that my brother got a gift and I didn’t. My dad told me to worry about what I have, not what others are getting.[/quote]This is a straw man…
Your dad didn’t take money from YOUR piggy bank to buy your brother the gift.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.