- This topic has 505 replies, 23 voices, and was last updated 15 years, 2 months ago by
Veritas.
-
AuthorPosts
-
April 15, 2009 at 6:01 AM #381828April 15, 2009 at 6:11 AM #381197
scaredyclassic
Participantin my opinion, and this is just an opinion, you have to be a little crazy to go to fight an unnecessary war. if we were truly defending our country there would be no hesitation for me to fight, or to send my chidlrne to fight, or for all of our leaders to send their chidlren to fight. these are no wars to defend the country. they’re wars to defend our interests. and you have to be very principled, very patriotic, and perhaps a bit mad to fight and die, or to send your childrne to die, for a principle as abstract as our interests, particularly when those interests don’t include “freedom”….
no slur on veters generally. ‘on average” veters are good people struggling with a bad situation. but i think disproportionately they have mental effects others don.t can we agree violent war change syou? can we agree it probably doesnt change you for the better? i dind’t mean theyr’e all crazy. but it’s a crazy situation.
April 15, 2009 at 6:11 AM #381468scaredyclassic
Participantin my opinion, and this is just an opinion, you have to be a little crazy to go to fight an unnecessary war. if we were truly defending our country there would be no hesitation for me to fight, or to send my chidlrne to fight, or for all of our leaders to send their chidlren to fight. these are no wars to defend the country. they’re wars to defend our interests. and you have to be very principled, very patriotic, and perhaps a bit mad to fight and die, or to send your childrne to die, for a principle as abstract as our interests, particularly when those interests don’t include “freedom”….
no slur on veters generally. ‘on average” veters are good people struggling with a bad situation. but i think disproportionately they have mental effects others don.t can we agree violent war change syou? can we agree it probably doesnt change you for the better? i dind’t mean theyr’e all crazy. but it’s a crazy situation.
April 15, 2009 at 6:11 AM #381657scaredyclassic
Participantin my opinion, and this is just an opinion, you have to be a little crazy to go to fight an unnecessary war. if we were truly defending our country there would be no hesitation for me to fight, or to send my chidlrne to fight, or for all of our leaders to send their chidlren to fight. these are no wars to defend the country. they’re wars to defend our interests. and you have to be very principled, very patriotic, and perhaps a bit mad to fight and die, or to send your childrne to die, for a principle as abstract as our interests, particularly when those interests don’t include “freedom”….
no slur on veters generally. ‘on average” veters are good people struggling with a bad situation. but i think disproportionately they have mental effects others don.t can we agree violent war change syou? can we agree it probably doesnt change you for the better? i dind’t mean theyr’e all crazy. but it’s a crazy situation.
April 15, 2009 at 6:11 AM #381704scaredyclassic
Participantin my opinion, and this is just an opinion, you have to be a little crazy to go to fight an unnecessary war. if we were truly defending our country there would be no hesitation for me to fight, or to send my chidlrne to fight, or for all of our leaders to send their chidlren to fight. these are no wars to defend the country. they’re wars to defend our interests. and you have to be very principled, very patriotic, and perhaps a bit mad to fight and die, or to send your childrne to die, for a principle as abstract as our interests, particularly when those interests don’t include “freedom”….
no slur on veters generally. ‘on average” veters are good people struggling with a bad situation. but i think disproportionately they have mental effects others don.t can we agree violent war change syou? can we agree it probably doesnt change you for the better? i dind’t mean theyr’e all crazy. but it’s a crazy situation.
April 15, 2009 at 6:11 AM #381833scaredyclassic
Participantin my opinion, and this is just an opinion, you have to be a little crazy to go to fight an unnecessary war. if we were truly defending our country there would be no hesitation for me to fight, or to send my chidlrne to fight, or for all of our leaders to send their chidlren to fight. these are no wars to defend the country. they’re wars to defend our interests. and you have to be very principled, very patriotic, and perhaps a bit mad to fight and die, or to send your childrne to die, for a principle as abstract as our interests, particularly when those interests don’t include “freedom”….
no slur on veters generally. ‘on average” veters are good people struggling with a bad situation. but i think disproportionately they have mental effects others don.t can we agree violent war change syou? can we agree it probably doesnt change you for the better? i dind’t mean theyr’e all crazy. but it’s a crazy situation.
April 15, 2009 at 6:15 AM #381202scaredyclassic
Participanti never mean to imply that there were groups of disaffected vets intending to overthrow the country.
all im saying is they can be scary.
this is an old problem.
COOL HAND LUKE….
disaffected vet.
tragic. heroic. and perceived to be needed to be controlled by society.
the same difficulty of returning wartime vets and how to reintegrate them is an old old problem…war is as anti-social a behavior as it gets…
April 15, 2009 at 6:15 AM #381473scaredyclassic
Participanti never mean to imply that there were groups of disaffected vets intending to overthrow the country.
all im saying is they can be scary.
this is an old problem.
COOL HAND LUKE….
disaffected vet.
tragic. heroic. and perceived to be needed to be controlled by society.
the same difficulty of returning wartime vets and how to reintegrate them is an old old problem…war is as anti-social a behavior as it gets…
April 15, 2009 at 6:15 AM #381662scaredyclassic
Participanti never mean to imply that there were groups of disaffected vets intending to overthrow the country.
all im saying is they can be scary.
this is an old problem.
COOL HAND LUKE….
disaffected vet.
tragic. heroic. and perceived to be needed to be controlled by society.
the same difficulty of returning wartime vets and how to reintegrate them is an old old problem…war is as anti-social a behavior as it gets…
April 15, 2009 at 6:15 AM #381709scaredyclassic
Participanti never mean to imply that there were groups of disaffected vets intending to overthrow the country.
all im saying is they can be scary.
this is an old problem.
COOL HAND LUKE….
disaffected vet.
tragic. heroic. and perceived to be needed to be controlled by society.
the same difficulty of returning wartime vets and how to reintegrate them is an old old problem…war is as anti-social a behavior as it gets…
April 15, 2009 at 6:15 AM #381838scaredyclassic
Participanti never mean to imply that there were groups of disaffected vets intending to overthrow the country.
all im saying is they can be scary.
this is an old problem.
COOL HAND LUKE….
disaffected vet.
tragic. heroic. and perceived to be needed to be controlled by society.
the same difficulty of returning wartime vets and how to reintegrate them is an old old problem…war is as anti-social a behavior as it gets…
April 15, 2009 at 6:25 AM #381207scaredyclassic
Participant.
allan said:
I spent three years in a combat zone. I returned home after a medical discharge and have been a model citizen since. I have friends that are former SOF operators, including Rangers, SEALs and Special Forces. If we, as a group, decided we were going on a tear, we’d be a nightmare for your average metro police department.We wouldn’t. You know why? We took an oath to defend this country and we respect America too much to even contemplate such acts.
+++++++++++ummm…that statement is a little scary. you won’t go on a murderous rampage because you ‘respect ” america too much? of all the reasons not to go ona murderousrampage, or “tear” or whatever “tear” means to you, respect for america is the least comforting or compeling reason I can think of. First because a country can change for good and bad, and levels of respect may change among people, based on hwo they are treated. people promise to love honor and respect their spouses forever, and that doesn’t work out,a nd while one may always love their country, they may not always respect it or its actions.
second, from a moral point of view, there are far more assuring and compelling reasons not to go ona “tear”…like…it’s always wrong to kill others not in war? like, religious moorings? like, love they neighbor as they self. or hell, i don’t know…it’s just the right thing to do, regardless of how you feel about your particulr country ant that aprticular point in time…….but luckily, all this violent capacity is held in check by “respect”.
i know im probably not getting to what you meant. but it is worrisome. there’s a lot of male energy coming back and not enough cop jobs to absorb them all…
April 15, 2009 at 6:25 AM #381477scaredyclassic
Participant.
allan said:
I spent three years in a combat zone. I returned home after a medical discharge and have been a model citizen since. I have friends that are former SOF operators, including Rangers, SEALs and Special Forces. If we, as a group, decided we were going on a tear, we’d be a nightmare for your average metro police department.We wouldn’t. You know why? We took an oath to defend this country and we respect America too much to even contemplate such acts.
+++++++++++ummm…that statement is a little scary. you won’t go on a murderous rampage because you ‘respect ” america too much? of all the reasons not to go ona murderousrampage, or “tear” or whatever “tear” means to you, respect for america is the least comforting or compeling reason I can think of. First because a country can change for good and bad, and levels of respect may change among people, based on hwo they are treated. people promise to love honor and respect their spouses forever, and that doesn’t work out,a nd while one may always love their country, they may not always respect it or its actions.
second, from a moral point of view, there are far more assuring and compelling reasons not to go ona “tear”…like…it’s always wrong to kill others not in war? like, religious moorings? like, love they neighbor as they self. or hell, i don’t know…it’s just the right thing to do, regardless of how you feel about your particulr country ant that aprticular point in time…….but luckily, all this violent capacity is held in check by “respect”.
i know im probably not getting to what you meant. but it is worrisome. there’s a lot of male energy coming back and not enough cop jobs to absorb them all…
April 15, 2009 at 6:25 AM #381667scaredyclassic
Participant.
allan said:
I spent three years in a combat zone. I returned home after a medical discharge and have been a model citizen since. I have friends that are former SOF operators, including Rangers, SEALs and Special Forces. If we, as a group, decided we were going on a tear, we’d be a nightmare for your average metro police department.We wouldn’t. You know why? We took an oath to defend this country and we respect America too much to even contemplate such acts.
+++++++++++ummm…that statement is a little scary. you won’t go on a murderous rampage because you ‘respect ” america too much? of all the reasons not to go ona murderousrampage, or “tear” or whatever “tear” means to you, respect for america is the least comforting or compeling reason I can think of. First because a country can change for good and bad, and levels of respect may change among people, based on hwo they are treated. people promise to love honor and respect their spouses forever, and that doesn’t work out,a nd while one may always love their country, they may not always respect it or its actions.
second, from a moral point of view, there are far more assuring and compelling reasons not to go ona “tear”…like…it’s always wrong to kill others not in war? like, religious moorings? like, love they neighbor as they self. or hell, i don’t know…it’s just the right thing to do, regardless of how you feel about your particulr country ant that aprticular point in time…….but luckily, all this violent capacity is held in check by “respect”.
i know im probably not getting to what you meant. but it is worrisome. there’s a lot of male energy coming back and not enough cop jobs to absorb them all…
April 15, 2009 at 6:25 AM #381714scaredyclassic
Participant.
allan said:
I spent three years in a combat zone. I returned home after a medical discharge and have been a model citizen since. I have friends that are former SOF operators, including Rangers, SEALs and Special Forces. If we, as a group, decided we were going on a tear, we’d be a nightmare for your average metro police department.We wouldn’t. You know why? We took an oath to defend this country and we respect America too much to even contemplate such acts.
+++++++++++ummm…that statement is a little scary. you won’t go on a murderous rampage because you ‘respect ” america too much? of all the reasons not to go ona murderousrampage, or “tear” or whatever “tear” means to you, respect for america is the least comforting or compeling reason I can think of. First because a country can change for good and bad, and levels of respect may change among people, based on hwo they are treated. people promise to love honor and respect their spouses forever, and that doesn’t work out,a nd while one may always love their country, they may not always respect it or its actions.
second, from a moral point of view, there are far more assuring and compelling reasons not to go ona “tear”…like…it’s always wrong to kill others not in war? like, religious moorings? like, love they neighbor as they self. or hell, i don’t know…it’s just the right thing to do, regardless of how you feel about your particulr country ant that aprticular point in time…….but luckily, all this violent capacity is held in check by “respect”.
i know im probably not getting to what you meant. but it is worrisome. there’s a lot of male energy coming back and not enough cop jobs to absorb them all…
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.