[quote=sdrealtor]Actually jenae’s sales were nopt used as comps for all other sales. All the agent sin the area knew there was something wrong with the sales [/quote]

OK, but did the appraisers know (and care)? If I remember, when stuff was going straight up, a lot of times appraisers really had to stretch to get an appraisal to come in where they needed it to. If they were bending the rules already, why would they pass up an opportunity to use one of those sales – which would legally pass for their purposes as a legitmate sale – as a comp?