Home › Forums › Financial Markets/Economics › Staggering credit numbers…
- This topic has 75 replies, 12 voices, and was last updated 15 years, 3 months ago by
patientrenter.
-
AuthorPosts
-
-
December 10, 2007 at 9:34 AM #11155
-
December 10, 2007 at 9:42 AM #112864
Anonymous
GuestBorrowers are loading up their credit cards on the way to bk court.
-
December 10, 2007 at 11:59 AM #113140
pencilneck
ParticipantDo either of you have a link to this data? I looked (not very hard, I admit) and couldn’t find it.
Thanks in advance!
-
December 10, 2007 at 12:07 PM #113159
GoUSC
ParticipantHere you go!
-
December 10, 2007 at 12:07 PM #113276
GoUSC
ParticipantHere you go!
-
December 10, 2007 at 12:07 PM #113319
GoUSC
ParticipantHere you go!
-
December 10, 2007 at 12:07 PM #113323
GoUSC
ParticipantHere you go!
-
December 10, 2007 at 12:07 PM #113360
GoUSC
ParticipantHere you go!
-
-
December 10, 2007 at 11:59 AM #113256
pencilneck
ParticipantDo either of you have a link to this data? I looked (not very hard, I admit) and couldn’t find it.
Thanks in advance!
-
December 10, 2007 at 11:59 AM #113298
pencilneck
ParticipantDo either of you have a link to this data? I looked (not very hard, I admit) and couldn’t find it.
Thanks in advance!
-
December 10, 2007 at 11:59 AM #113302
pencilneck
ParticipantDo either of you have a link to this data? I looked (not very hard, I admit) and couldn’t find it.
Thanks in advance!
-
December 10, 2007 at 11:59 AM #113340
pencilneck
ParticipantDo either of you have a link to this data? I looked (not very hard, I admit) and couldn’t find it.
Thanks in advance!
-
December 10, 2007 at 5:21 PM #113414
Arty
Participant“Borrowers are loading up their credit cards on the way to bk court.”
If it is that simple after the law change…I thought you can no longer declear chapter 7 and have your credit cards charges just disappear like that.
-
December 11, 2007 at 12:50 AM #113839
bubba99
Participant“If it is that simple after the law change…I thought you can no longer declear chapter 7 and have your credit cards charges just disappear like that.”
Correct, Chapter 7 bankruptcy is only available to a few – no income people, and then only after month of “credit counseling”. And even then the judge can force them to chapter 13 if it is mostly consumer debt.
The rest will need to develop a payment plan under Chapter 13, and pay for the rest of their lives.
Unless Paulsen et al create a new bailout for credit card debtors.
-
December 11, 2007 at 5:47 AM #113884
4plexowner
ParticipantDoes anyone know what happens to the interest rate on credit card debts after going through bankruptcy?
Some of the things I read indicate that a single late payment on ANY credit card can result in ALL the credit cards the consumer uses raising their interest rates to a very high rate (I think I have read 29% but that is ridiculously high)
So a consumer gets into trouble, has a late credit card payment and the next thing they know all of their cards are charging them 20%+ interest – a few months of this and they head to the bankruptcy court
I assume the bankruptcy process modifies the consumer’s debt so the monthly payment is manageable (interest rate and amount of payment)
I hope that the bankruptcy court isn’t sending debtors back into the world with debt charging over 20% interest – if they are, the term ‘debt slave’ is appropriate for these unfortunate consumers – does anyone have insight into the bankruptcy process?
-
December 11, 2007 at 5:47 AM #114001
4plexowner
ParticipantDoes anyone know what happens to the interest rate on credit card debts after going through bankruptcy?
Some of the things I read indicate that a single late payment on ANY credit card can result in ALL the credit cards the consumer uses raising their interest rates to a very high rate (I think I have read 29% but that is ridiculously high)
So a consumer gets into trouble, has a late credit card payment and the next thing they know all of their cards are charging them 20%+ interest – a few months of this and they head to the bankruptcy court
I assume the bankruptcy process modifies the consumer’s debt so the monthly payment is manageable (interest rate and amount of payment)
I hope that the bankruptcy court isn’t sending debtors back into the world with debt charging over 20% interest – if they are, the term ‘debt slave’ is appropriate for these unfortunate consumers – does anyone have insight into the bankruptcy process?
-
December 11, 2007 at 5:47 AM #114045
4plexowner
ParticipantDoes anyone know what happens to the interest rate on credit card debts after going through bankruptcy?
Some of the things I read indicate that a single late payment on ANY credit card can result in ALL the credit cards the consumer uses raising their interest rates to a very high rate (I think I have read 29% but that is ridiculously high)
So a consumer gets into trouble, has a late credit card payment and the next thing they know all of their cards are charging them 20%+ interest – a few months of this and they head to the bankruptcy court
I assume the bankruptcy process modifies the consumer’s debt so the monthly payment is manageable (interest rate and amount of payment)
I hope that the bankruptcy court isn’t sending debtors back into the world with debt charging over 20% interest – if they are, the term ‘debt slave’ is appropriate for these unfortunate consumers – does anyone have insight into the bankruptcy process?
-
December 11, 2007 at 5:47 AM #114048
4plexowner
ParticipantDoes anyone know what happens to the interest rate on credit card debts after going through bankruptcy?
Some of the things I read indicate that a single late payment on ANY credit card can result in ALL the credit cards the consumer uses raising their interest rates to a very high rate (I think I have read 29% but that is ridiculously high)
So a consumer gets into trouble, has a late credit card payment and the next thing they know all of their cards are charging them 20%+ interest – a few months of this and they head to the bankruptcy court
I assume the bankruptcy process modifies the consumer’s debt so the monthly payment is manageable (interest rate and amount of payment)
I hope that the bankruptcy court isn’t sending debtors back into the world with debt charging over 20% interest – if they are, the term ‘debt slave’ is appropriate for these unfortunate consumers – does anyone have insight into the bankruptcy process?
-
December 11, 2007 at 5:47 AM #114084
4plexowner
ParticipantDoes anyone know what happens to the interest rate on credit card debts after going through bankruptcy?
Some of the things I read indicate that a single late payment on ANY credit card can result in ALL the credit cards the consumer uses raising their interest rates to a very high rate (I think I have read 29% but that is ridiculously high)
So a consumer gets into trouble, has a late credit card payment and the next thing they know all of their cards are charging them 20%+ interest – a few months of this and they head to the bankruptcy court
I assume the bankruptcy process modifies the consumer’s debt so the monthly payment is manageable (interest rate and amount of payment)
I hope that the bankruptcy court isn’t sending debtors back into the world with debt charging over 20% interest – if they are, the term ‘debt slave’ is appropriate for these unfortunate consumers – does anyone have insight into the bankruptcy process?
-
December 11, 2007 at 12:50 AM #113956
bubba99
Participant“If it is that simple after the law change…I thought you can no longer declear chapter 7 and have your credit cards charges just disappear like that.”
Correct, Chapter 7 bankruptcy is only available to a few – no income people, and then only after month of “credit counseling”. And even then the judge can force them to chapter 13 if it is mostly consumer debt.
The rest will need to develop a payment plan under Chapter 13, and pay for the rest of their lives.
Unless Paulsen et al create a new bailout for credit card debtors.
-
December 11, 2007 at 12:50 AM #114000
bubba99
Participant“If it is that simple after the law change…I thought you can no longer declear chapter 7 and have your credit cards charges just disappear like that.”
Correct, Chapter 7 bankruptcy is only available to a few – no income people, and then only after month of “credit counseling”. And even then the judge can force them to chapter 13 if it is mostly consumer debt.
The rest will need to develop a payment plan under Chapter 13, and pay for the rest of their lives.
Unless Paulsen et al create a new bailout for credit card debtors.
-
December 11, 2007 at 12:50 AM #114003
bubba99
Participant“If it is that simple after the law change…I thought you can no longer declear chapter 7 and have your credit cards charges just disappear like that.”
Correct, Chapter 7 bankruptcy is only available to a few – no income people, and then only after month of “credit counseling”. And even then the judge can force them to chapter 13 if it is mostly consumer debt.
The rest will need to develop a payment plan under Chapter 13, and pay for the rest of their lives.
Unless Paulsen et al create a new bailout for credit card debtors.
-
December 11, 2007 at 12:50 AM #114039
bubba99
Participant“If it is that simple after the law change…I thought you can no longer declear chapter 7 and have your credit cards charges just disappear like that.”
Correct, Chapter 7 bankruptcy is only available to a few – no income people, and then only after month of “credit counseling”. And even then the judge can force them to chapter 13 if it is mostly consumer debt.
The rest will need to develop a payment plan under Chapter 13, and pay for the rest of their lives.
Unless Paulsen et al create a new bailout for credit card debtors.
-
-
December 10, 2007 at 5:21 PM #113532
Arty
Participant“Borrowers are loading up their credit cards on the way to bk court.”
If it is that simple after the law change…I thought you can no longer declear chapter 7 and have your credit cards charges just disappear like that.
-
December 10, 2007 at 5:21 PM #113574
Arty
Participant“Borrowers are loading up their credit cards on the way to bk court.”
If it is that simple after the law change…I thought you can no longer declear chapter 7 and have your credit cards charges just disappear like that.
-
December 10, 2007 at 5:21 PM #113580
Arty
Participant“Borrowers are loading up their credit cards on the way to bk court.”
If it is that simple after the law change…I thought you can no longer declear chapter 7 and have your credit cards charges just disappear like that.
-
December 10, 2007 at 5:21 PM #113613
Arty
Participant“Borrowers are loading up their credit cards on the way to bk court.”
If it is that simple after the law change…I thought you can no longer declear chapter 7 and have your credit cards charges just disappear like that.
-
-
December 10, 2007 at 9:42 AM #112982
Anonymous
GuestBorrowers are loading up their credit cards on the way to bk court.
-
December 10, 2007 at 9:42 AM #113022
Anonymous
GuestBorrowers are loading up their credit cards on the way to bk court.
-
December 10, 2007 at 9:42 AM #113029
Anonymous
GuestBorrowers are loading up their credit cards on the way to bk court.
-
December 10, 2007 at 9:42 AM #113063
Anonymous
GuestBorrowers are loading up their credit cards on the way to bk court.
-
December 10, 2007 at 12:10 PM #113169
bsrsharma
ParticipantAverage car loan is $30,000 with a 61 month maturity
What are the usual "Average cars" driven by J6P? 32K seems a bit steep. Camry is 17-25K Invoice and 18-28K MSRP. F-150 starts 17K MSRP. And they can only pony up $1500 to buy these toys?
-
December 10, 2007 at 12:34 PM #113180
kev374
Participantpart of the problem is because people can so easily get credit and then just walk away from their debt when they feel like not paying.
Thanks to our government with schemes like the current bailout plan, the concept of individual responsiblity in this country is all but dead.
I support reserving Bankruptcy for those that have been TRULY unfortunate and this means they fell seriously ill and could not work or they lost their job and used their credit cards to buy groceries to eat or feed their children. Apart from that enslave them and make them pay their FULL obligations. I have no sympathy for those that have bought $5 Starbucks lattes and now cry crocodile tears or took out loans way more they could afford since they felt entitled to own a home!
-
December 10, 2007 at 12:34 PM #113296
kev374
Participantpart of the problem is because people can so easily get credit and then just walk away from their debt when they feel like not paying.
Thanks to our government with schemes like the current bailout plan, the concept of individual responsiblity in this country is all but dead.
I support reserving Bankruptcy for those that have been TRULY unfortunate and this means they fell seriously ill and could not work or they lost their job and used their credit cards to buy groceries to eat or feed their children. Apart from that enslave them and make them pay their FULL obligations. I have no sympathy for those that have bought $5 Starbucks lattes and now cry crocodile tears or took out loans way more they could afford since they felt entitled to own a home!
-
December 10, 2007 at 12:34 PM #113339
kev374
Participantpart of the problem is because people can so easily get credit and then just walk away from their debt when they feel like not paying.
Thanks to our government with schemes like the current bailout plan, the concept of individual responsiblity in this country is all but dead.
I support reserving Bankruptcy for those that have been TRULY unfortunate and this means they fell seriously ill and could not work or they lost their job and used their credit cards to buy groceries to eat or feed their children. Apart from that enslave them and make them pay their FULL obligations. I have no sympathy for those that have bought $5 Starbucks lattes and now cry crocodile tears or took out loans way more they could afford since they felt entitled to own a home!
-
December 10, 2007 at 12:34 PM #113343
kev374
Participantpart of the problem is because people can so easily get credit and then just walk away from their debt when they feel like not paying.
Thanks to our government with schemes like the current bailout plan, the concept of individual responsiblity in this country is all but dead.
I support reserving Bankruptcy for those that have been TRULY unfortunate and this means they fell seriously ill and could not work or they lost their job and used their credit cards to buy groceries to eat or feed their children. Apart from that enslave them and make them pay their FULL obligations. I have no sympathy for those that have bought $5 Starbucks lattes and now cry crocodile tears or took out loans way more they could afford since they felt entitled to own a home!
-
December 10, 2007 at 12:34 PM #113380
kev374
Participantpart of the problem is because people can so easily get credit and then just walk away from their debt when they feel like not paying.
Thanks to our government with schemes like the current bailout plan, the concept of individual responsiblity in this country is all but dead.
I support reserving Bankruptcy for those that have been TRULY unfortunate and this means they fell seriously ill and could not work or they lost their job and used their credit cards to buy groceries to eat or feed their children. Apart from that enslave them and make them pay their FULL obligations. I have no sympathy for those that have bought $5 Starbucks lattes and now cry crocodile tears or took out loans way more they could afford since they felt entitled to own a home!
-
December 10, 2007 at 5:28 PM #113438
GoUSC
ParticipantI have no idea Bsrsharma. But that’s what the numbers say. Lots of people bought $50k SUV’s and such with 100% loans.
-
December 10, 2007 at 5:41 PM #113448
5yes
ParticipantMy brother just got out of college and got his first job, so he went out and bought $40,000 truck with 100% financing on an 80 month loan! He wouldn’t listen to anyone’s (including my) advice about it, even though I am much older and have a better job and have never bought a car even close to half that price!
-
December 10, 2007 at 5:41 PM #113566
5yes
ParticipantMy brother just got out of college and got his first job, so he went out and bought $40,000 truck with 100% financing on an 80 month loan! He wouldn’t listen to anyone’s (including my) advice about it, even though I am much older and have a better job and have never bought a car even close to half that price!
-
December 10, 2007 at 5:41 PM #113609
5yes
ParticipantMy brother just got out of college and got his first job, so he went out and bought $40,000 truck with 100% financing on an 80 month loan! He wouldn’t listen to anyone’s (including my) advice about it, even though I am much older and have a better job and have never bought a car even close to half that price!
-
December 10, 2007 at 5:41 PM #113615
5yes
ParticipantMy brother just got out of college and got his first job, so he went out and bought $40,000 truck with 100% financing on an 80 month loan! He wouldn’t listen to anyone’s (including my) advice about it, even though I am much older and have a better job and have never bought a car even close to half that price!
-
December 10, 2007 at 5:41 PM #113650
5yes
ParticipantMy brother just got out of college and got his first job, so he went out and bought $40,000 truck with 100% financing on an 80 month loan! He wouldn’t listen to anyone’s (including my) advice about it, even though I am much older and have a better job and have never bought a car even close to half that price!
-
December 10, 2007 at 5:45 PM #113452
(former)FormerSanDiegan
ParticipantWhat are the usual “Average cars” driven by J6P? 32K seems a bit steep. Camry is 17-25K Invoice and 18-28K MSRP. F-150 starts 17K MSRP. And they can only pony up $1500 to buy these toys?
It didn’t say the loan on an average car, like a Camry. It said the average car loan. A few expensive samples can really skew the numbers.
Consider a sample that has 5 average sedans (e.g.Camry’s at 25K each) and one Range Rover for 75K, with 10% down.
The average loan would be 30K. -
December 10, 2007 at 5:45 PM #113571
(former)FormerSanDiegan
ParticipantWhat are the usual “Average cars” driven by J6P? 32K seems a bit steep. Camry is 17-25K Invoice and 18-28K MSRP. F-150 starts 17K MSRP. And they can only pony up $1500 to buy these toys?
It didn’t say the loan on an average car, like a Camry. It said the average car loan. A few expensive samples can really skew the numbers.
Consider a sample that has 5 average sedans (e.g.Camry’s at 25K each) and one Range Rover for 75K, with 10% down.
The average loan would be 30K. -
December 10, 2007 at 5:45 PM #113614
(former)FormerSanDiegan
ParticipantWhat are the usual “Average cars” driven by J6P? 32K seems a bit steep. Camry is 17-25K Invoice and 18-28K MSRP. F-150 starts 17K MSRP. And they can only pony up $1500 to buy these toys?
It didn’t say the loan on an average car, like a Camry. It said the average car loan. A few expensive samples can really skew the numbers.
Consider a sample that has 5 average sedans (e.g.Camry’s at 25K each) and one Range Rover for 75K, with 10% down.
The average loan would be 30K. -
December 10, 2007 at 5:45 PM #113620
(former)FormerSanDiegan
ParticipantWhat are the usual “Average cars” driven by J6P? 32K seems a bit steep. Camry is 17-25K Invoice and 18-28K MSRP. F-150 starts 17K MSRP. And they can only pony up $1500 to buy these toys?
It didn’t say the loan on an average car, like a Camry. It said the average car loan. A few expensive samples can really skew the numbers.
Consider a sample that has 5 average sedans (e.g.Camry’s at 25K each) and one Range Rover for 75K, with 10% down.
The average loan would be 30K. -
December 10, 2007 at 5:45 PM #113655
(former)FormerSanDiegan
ParticipantWhat are the usual “Average cars” driven by J6P? 32K seems a bit steep. Camry is 17-25K Invoice and 18-28K MSRP. F-150 starts 17K MSRP. And they can only pony up $1500 to buy these toys?
It didn’t say the loan on an average car, like a Camry. It said the average car loan. A few expensive samples can really skew the numbers.
Consider a sample that has 5 average sedans (e.g.Camry’s at 25K each) and one Range Rover for 75K, with 10% down.
The average loan would be 30K.
-
-
December 10, 2007 at 5:28 PM #113557
GoUSC
ParticipantI have no idea Bsrsharma. But that’s what the numbers say. Lots of people bought $50k SUV’s and such with 100% loans.
-
December 10, 2007 at 5:28 PM #113599
GoUSC
ParticipantI have no idea Bsrsharma. But that’s what the numbers say. Lots of people bought $50k SUV’s and such with 100% loans.
-
December 10, 2007 at 5:28 PM #113605
GoUSC
ParticipantI have no idea Bsrsharma. But that’s what the numbers say. Lots of people bought $50k SUV’s and such with 100% loans.
-
December 10, 2007 at 5:28 PM #113640
GoUSC
ParticipantI have no idea Bsrsharma. But that’s what the numbers say. Lots of people bought $50k SUV’s and such with 100% loans.
-
-
December 10, 2007 at 12:10 PM #113286
bsrsharma
ParticipantAverage car loan is $30,000 with a 61 month maturity
What are the usual "Average cars" driven by J6P? 32K seems a bit steep. Camry is 17-25K Invoice and 18-28K MSRP. F-150 starts 17K MSRP. And they can only pony up $1500 to buy these toys?
-
December 10, 2007 at 12:10 PM #113329
bsrsharma
ParticipantAverage car loan is $30,000 with a 61 month maturity
What are the usual "Average cars" driven by J6P? 32K seems a bit steep. Camry is 17-25K Invoice and 18-28K MSRP. F-150 starts 17K MSRP. And they can only pony up $1500 to buy these toys?
-
December 10, 2007 at 12:10 PM #113333
bsrsharma
ParticipantAverage car loan is $30,000 with a 61 month maturity
What are the usual "Average cars" driven by J6P? 32K seems a bit steep. Camry is 17-25K Invoice and 18-28K MSRP. F-150 starts 17K MSRP. And they can only pony up $1500 to buy these toys?
-
December 10, 2007 at 12:10 PM #113370
bsrsharma
ParticipantAverage car loan is $30,000 with a 61 month maturity
What are the usual "Average cars" driven by J6P? 32K seems a bit steep. Camry is 17-25K Invoice and 18-28K MSRP. F-150 starts 17K MSRP. And they can only pony up $1500 to buy these toys?
-
December 10, 2007 at 5:52 PM #113462
Trojan4Life
ParticipantThat’s insane! I had a Corvette that I financed $25K on at 0% and my payment was in the neighborhood of $600. I thought that was a ton of money in 2004! I have neighbors who don’t have two nickels to rub together who go out and lease a new car when they get to the point that they need to replace tires because they don’t have the $$$ to buy new tires. This is absolutely insane.
On a different yet related topic, I found a very nice brand new townhome in Redondo Beach up here in LA. Really nicely done Med style, high quality finish materials (granite, travertine, crown molding, etc). It was completed and originally listed in Sep 07 for $859K, now reduced to $829K. Agent claims the seller/builder will refund $$$ to match sales price with last unit sold (i.e buy now for $829K and if the last of the ten units sells for $759K, I would get $70K back). Sounds too good to be true…so we know the adage.
Do you think I’d have a crack at a deal at a $750K offer? it’s blocks from the beach, good schools for LA, etc…
Also, we’re dealing with only being able to put about $100K down, are there still loan products out there to help me without burying me?-
December 10, 2007 at 8:40 PM #113607
patientrenter
ParticipantTrojan4Life, I know you didn’t ask for financial planning advice, but I’ll offer some anyway. If you asked yourself these questions, what would your answer be:
1. What’s my net income? (I)
2. What are my annual expenses, including everything (like occasional car replacement and health expenses)? (E)
3. How many years do I want to commit to working for? (W)
4. How many years after retirement am I prepared to run out of all my money? (R)
5. What is (I x W) – [E x (W+R)]?
I think you see where I’m going with the (simple) math.
Patient renter in OC
-
December 11, 2007 at 7:36 AM #113932
Trojan4Life
ParticipantPR, not sure what you’re getting at with your reply.
I’ll have approximately $120K in net income (not including bonuses) and realistically will be in the home for about 12-15 years (once my youngest is established in college, which I already have fully funded). I am in a little different situation from a lot of you in that I am going to be receiving a govt. (military) pension starting this summer at the ripe old age of 42. This retirement check is for life and will start out at approximately $3,100 net and will adjust upward each year. Military retired pay rises each year to ensure that inflation does not erode the purchasing power of retirees, and raises are based on the CPI.
Annual expenses is kind of tricky, because I don’t need to fund a lot of the retirement savings most folks do as aggressively due to my military retirement. We have no debt (as in $0), two newer cars paid off. Kids college funds are already set (pre-paid plan in Florida for 4-yrs of university study) and if they want to go to school in California they will be afforded free tuition due to my injuries received on active duty.
All told, I anticipate a mortgage PITI of (gasp) $5,300 per month, with a net income of slightly over $10K per month.
I’d be more thatn happy to talk to you off-line at [email protected]
Thanks
-
December 11, 2007 at 10:04 PM #114686
patientrenter
ParticipantTrojan, sorry, I didn’t mean to be obtuse. What I was getting at is that it might be helpful to assess how much you can afford to pay for a home based not on monthly mortgage payments, but rather how much the purchase price is versus your lifetime income and outgo.
For example, if you applied this method using these assumptions (that I just made up):
1. Income (net of taxes and other deductions) = $120K+37K = $157K
2. Expenses (excluding non-expense items such as savings) = $70K.
3. Number of years you’re OK with committing to working at $120K job = 15.
4. Number of years after you’ve quit working the $120K job at which you’re prepared to run out of cash in your old age = 90 – (42+15) = 33
The you’d get total lifetime savings = 15 x 157 + 33 x 37 – (15+33) x 70 = $216K.
So if you have no other things you want to save for, then you can afford about $200K for a home. Plug in the numbers you think are appropriate. It’s just a way to strip out all the “noise” from complicated assumptions about interest and other investment income and inflation. I hope this helps as an alternative view.
Patient renter in OC
-
December 11, 2007 at 10:04 PM #114810
patientrenter
ParticipantTrojan, sorry, I didn’t mean to be obtuse. What I was getting at is that it might be helpful to assess how much you can afford to pay for a home based not on monthly mortgage payments, but rather how much the purchase price is versus your lifetime income and outgo.
For example, if you applied this method using these assumptions (that I just made up):
1. Income (net of taxes and other deductions) = $120K+37K = $157K
2. Expenses (excluding non-expense items such as savings) = $70K.
3. Number of years you’re OK with committing to working at $120K job = 15.
4. Number of years after you’ve quit working the $120K job at which you’re prepared to run out of cash in your old age = 90 – (42+15) = 33
The you’d get total lifetime savings = 15 x 157 + 33 x 37 – (15+33) x 70 = $216K.
So if you have no other things you want to save for, then you can afford about $200K for a home. Plug in the numbers you think are appropriate. It’s just a way to strip out all the “noise” from complicated assumptions about interest and other investment income and inflation. I hope this helps as an alternative view.
Patient renter in OC
-
December 11, 2007 at 10:04 PM #114848
patientrenter
ParticipantTrojan, sorry, I didn’t mean to be obtuse. What I was getting at is that it might be helpful to assess how much you can afford to pay for a home based not on monthly mortgage payments, but rather how much the purchase price is versus your lifetime income and outgo.
For example, if you applied this method using these assumptions (that I just made up):
1. Income (net of taxes and other deductions) = $120K+37K = $157K
2. Expenses (excluding non-expense items such as savings) = $70K.
3. Number of years you’re OK with committing to working at $120K job = 15.
4. Number of years after you’ve quit working the $120K job at which you’re prepared to run out of cash in your old age = 90 – (42+15) = 33
The you’d get total lifetime savings = 15 x 157 + 33 x 37 – (15+33) x 70 = $216K.
So if you have no other things you want to save for, then you can afford about $200K for a home. Plug in the numbers you think are appropriate. It’s just a way to strip out all the “noise” from complicated assumptions about interest and other investment income and inflation. I hope this helps as an alternative view.
Patient renter in OC
-
December 11, 2007 at 10:04 PM #114852
patientrenter
ParticipantTrojan, sorry, I didn’t mean to be obtuse. What I was getting at is that it might be helpful to assess how much you can afford to pay for a home based not on monthly mortgage payments, but rather how much the purchase price is versus your lifetime income and outgo.
For example, if you applied this method using these assumptions (that I just made up):
1. Income (net of taxes and other deductions) = $120K+37K = $157K
2. Expenses (excluding non-expense items such as savings) = $70K.
3. Number of years you’re OK with committing to working at $120K job = 15.
4. Number of years after you’ve quit working the $120K job at which you’re prepared to run out of cash in your old age = 90 – (42+15) = 33
The you’d get total lifetime savings = 15 x 157 + 33 x 37 – (15+33) x 70 = $216K.
So if you have no other things you want to save for, then you can afford about $200K for a home. Plug in the numbers you think are appropriate. It’s just a way to strip out all the “noise” from complicated assumptions about interest and other investment income and inflation. I hope this helps as an alternative view.
Patient renter in OC
-
December 11, 2007 at 10:04 PM #114889
patientrenter
ParticipantTrojan, sorry, I didn’t mean to be obtuse. What I was getting at is that it might be helpful to assess how much you can afford to pay for a home based not on monthly mortgage payments, but rather how much the purchase price is versus your lifetime income and outgo.
For example, if you applied this method using these assumptions (that I just made up):
1. Income (net of taxes and other deductions) = $120K+37K = $157K
2. Expenses (excluding non-expense items such as savings) = $70K.
3. Number of years you’re OK with committing to working at $120K job = 15.
4. Number of years after you’ve quit working the $120K job at which you’re prepared to run out of cash in your old age = 90 – (42+15) = 33
The you’d get total lifetime savings = 15 x 157 + 33 x 37 – (15+33) x 70 = $216K.
So if you have no other things you want to save for, then you can afford about $200K for a home. Plug in the numbers you think are appropriate. It’s just a way to strip out all the “noise” from complicated assumptions about interest and other investment income and inflation. I hope this helps as an alternative view.
Patient renter in OC
-
December 11, 2007 at 7:36 AM #114052
Trojan4Life
ParticipantPR, not sure what you’re getting at with your reply.
I’ll have approximately $120K in net income (not including bonuses) and realistically will be in the home for about 12-15 years (once my youngest is established in college, which I already have fully funded). I am in a little different situation from a lot of you in that I am going to be receiving a govt. (military) pension starting this summer at the ripe old age of 42. This retirement check is for life and will start out at approximately $3,100 net and will adjust upward each year. Military retired pay rises each year to ensure that inflation does not erode the purchasing power of retirees, and raises are based on the CPI.
Annual expenses is kind of tricky, because I don’t need to fund a lot of the retirement savings most folks do as aggressively due to my military retirement. We have no debt (as in $0), two newer cars paid off. Kids college funds are already set (pre-paid plan in Florida for 4-yrs of university study) and if they want to go to school in California they will be afforded free tuition due to my injuries received on active duty.
All told, I anticipate a mortgage PITI of (gasp) $5,300 per month, with a net income of slightly over $10K per month.
I’d be more thatn happy to talk to you off-line at [email protected]
Thanks
-
December 11, 2007 at 7:36 AM #114095
Trojan4Life
ParticipantPR, not sure what you’re getting at with your reply.
I’ll have approximately $120K in net income (not including bonuses) and realistically will be in the home for about 12-15 years (once my youngest is established in college, which I already have fully funded). I am in a little different situation from a lot of you in that I am going to be receiving a govt. (military) pension starting this summer at the ripe old age of 42. This retirement check is for life and will start out at approximately $3,100 net and will adjust upward each year. Military retired pay rises each year to ensure that inflation does not erode the purchasing power of retirees, and raises are based on the CPI.
Annual expenses is kind of tricky, because I don’t need to fund a lot of the retirement savings most folks do as aggressively due to my military retirement. We have no debt (as in $0), two newer cars paid off. Kids college funds are already set (pre-paid plan in Florida for 4-yrs of university study) and if they want to go to school in California they will be afforded free tuition due to my injuries received on active duty.
All told, I anticipate a mortgage PITI of (gasp) $5,300 per month, with a net income of slightly over $10K per month.
I’d be more thatn happy to talk to you off-line at [email protected]
Thanks
-
December 11, 2007 at 7:36 AM #114099
Trojan4Life
ParticipantPR, not sure what you’re getting at with your reply.
I’ll have approximately $120K in net income (not including bonuses) and realistically will be in the home for about 12-15 years (once my youngest is established in college, which I already have fully funded). I am in a little different situation from a lot of you in that I am going to be receiving a govt. (military) pension starting this summer at the ripe old age of 42. This retirement check is for life and will start out at approximately $3,100 net and will adjust upward each year. Military retired pay rises each year to ensure that inflation does not erode the purchasing power of retirees, and raises are based on the CPI.
Annual expenses is kind of tricky, because I don’t need to fund a lot of the retirement savings most folks do as aggressively due to my military retirement. We have no debt (as in $0), two newer cars paid off. Kids college funds are already set (pre-paid plan in Florida for 4-yrs of university study) and if they want to go to school in California they will be afforded free tuition due to my injuries received on active duty.
All told, I anticipate a mortgage PITI of (gasp) $5,300 per month, with a net income of slightly over $10K per month.
I’d be more thatn happy to talk to you off-line at [email protected]
Thanks
-
December 11, 2007 at 7:36 AM #114132
Trojan4Life
ParticipantPR, not sure what you’re getting at with your reply.
I’ll have approximately $120K in net income (not including bonuses) and realistically will be in the home for about 12-15 years (once my youngest is established in college, which I already have fully funded). I am in a little different situation from a lot of you in that I am going to be receiving a govt. (military) pension starting this summer at the ripe old age of 42. This retirement check is for life and will start out at approximately $3,100 net and will adjust upward each year. Military retired pay rises each year to ensure that inflation does not erode the purchasing power of retirees, and raises are based on the CPI.
Annual expenses is kind of tricky, because I don’t need to fund a lot of the retirement savings most folks do as aggressively due to my military retirement. We have no debt (as in $0), two newer cars paid off. Kids college funds are already set (pre-paid plan in Florida for 4-yrs of university study) and if they want to go to school in California they will be afforded free tuition due to my injuries received on active duty.
All told, I anticipate a mortgage PITI of (gasp) $5,300 per month, with a net income of slightly over $10K per month.
I’d be more thatn happy to talk to you off-line at [email protected]
Thanks
-
-
December 10, 2007 at 8:40 PM #113727
patientrenter
ParticipantTrojan4Life, I know you didn’t ask for financial planning advice, but I’ll offer some anyway. If you asked yourself these questions, what would your answer be:
1. What’s my net income? (I)
2. What are my annual expenses, including everything (like occasional car replacement and health expenses)? (E)
3. How many years do I want to commit to working for? (W)
4. How many years after retirement am I prepared to run out of all my money? (R)
5. What is (I x W) – [E x (W+R)]?
I think you see where I’m going with the (simple) math.
Patient renter in OC
-
December 10, 2007 at 8:40 PM #113767
patientrenter
ParticipantTrojan4Life, I know you didn’t ask for financial planning advice, but I’ll offer some anyway. If you asked yourself these questions, what would your answer be:
1. What’s my net income? (I)
2. What are my annual expenses, including everything (like occasional car replacement and health expenses)? (E)
3. How many years do I want to commit to working for? (W)
4. How many years after retirement am I prepared to run out of all my money? (R)
5. What is (I x W) – [E x (W+R)]?
I think you see where I’m going with the (simple) math.
Patient renter in OC
-
December 10, 2007 at 8:40 PM #113771
patientrenter
ParticipantTrojan4Life, I know you didn’t ask for financial planning advice, but I’ll offer some anyway. If you asked yourself these questions, what would your answer be:
1. What’s my net income? (I)
2. What are my annual expenses, including everything (like occasional car replacement and health expenses)? (E)
3. How many years do I want to commit to working for? (W)
4. How many years after retirement am I prepared to run out of all my money? (R)
5. What is (I x W) – [E x (W+R)]?
I think you see where I’m going with the (simple) math.
Patient renter in OC
-
December 10, 2007 at 8:40 PM #113810
patientrenter
ParticipantTrojan4Life, I know you didn’t ask for financial planning advice, but I’ll offer some anyway. If you asked yourself these questions, what would your answer be:
1. What’s my net income? (I)
2. What are my annual expenses, including everything (like occasional car replacement and health expenses)? (E)
3. How many years do I want to commit to working for? (W)
4. How many years after retirement am I prepared to run out of all my money? (R)
5. What is (I x W) – [E x (W+R)]?
I think you see where I’m going with the (simple) math.
Patient renter in OC
-
-
December 10, 2007 at 5:52 PM #113581
Trojan4Life
ParticipantThat’s insane! I had a Corvette that I financed $25K on at 0% and my payment was in the neighborhood of $600. I thought that was a ton of money in 2004! I have neighbors who don’t have two nickels to rub together who go out and lease a new car when they get to the point that they need to replace tires because they don’t have the $$$ to buy new tires. This is absolutely insane.
On a different yet related topic, I found a very nice brand new townhome in Redondo Beach up here in LA. Really nicely done Med style, high quality finish materials (granite, travertine, crown molding, etc). It was completed and originally listed in Sep 07 for $859K, now reduced to $829K. Agent claims the seller/builder will refund $$$ to match sales price with last unit sold (i.e buy now for $829K and if the last of the ten units sells for $759K, I would get $70K back). Sounds too good to be true…so we know the adage.
Do you think I’d have a crack at a deal at a $750K offer? it’s blocks from the beach, good schools for LA, etc…
Also, we’re dealing with only being able to put about $100K down, are there still loan products out there to help me without burying me? -
December 10, 2007 at 5:52 PM #113623
Trojan4Life
ParticipantThat’s insane! I had a Corvette that I financed $25K on at 0% and my payment was in the neighborhood of $600. I thought that was a ton of money in 2004! I have neighbors who don’t have two nickels to rub together who go out and lease a new car when they get to the point that they need to replace tires because they don’t have the $$$ to buy new tires. This is absolutely insane.
On a different yet related topic, I found a very nice brand new townhome in Redondo Beach up here in LA. Really nicely done Med style, high quality finish materials (granite, travertine, crown molding, etc). It was completed and originally listed in Sep 07 for $859K, now reduced to $829K. Agent claims the seller/builder will refund $$$ to match sales price with last unit sold (i.e buy now for $829K and if the last of the ten units sells for $759K, I would get $70K back). Sounds too good to be true…so we know the adage.
Do you think I’d have a crack at a deal at a $750K offer? it’s blocks from the beach, good schools for LA, etc…
Also, we’re dealing with only being able to put about $100K down, are there still loan products out there to help me without burying me? -
December 10, 2007 at 5:52 PM #113629
Trojan4Life
ParticipantThat’s insane! I had a Corvette that I financed $25K on at 0% and my payment was in the neighborhood of $600. I thought that was a ton of money in 2004! I have neighbors who don’t have two nickels to rub together who go out and lease a new car when they get to the point that they need to replace tires because they don’t have the $$$ to buy new tires. This is absolutely insane.
On a different yet related topic, I found a very nice brand new townhome in Redondo Beach up here in LA. Really nicely done Med style, high quality finish materials (granite, travertine, crown molding, etc). It was completed and originally listed in Sep 07 for $859K, now reduced to $829K. Agent claims the seller/builder will refund $$$ to match sales price with last unit sold (i.e buy now for $829K and if the last of the ten units sells for $759K, I would get $70K back). Sounds too good to be true…so we know the adage.
Do you think I’d have a crack at a deal at a $750K offer? it’s blocks from the beach, good schools for LA, etc…
Also, we’re dealing with only being able to put about $100K down, are there still loan products out there to help me without burying me? -
December 10, 2007 at 5:52 PM #113664
Trojan4Life
ParticipantThat’s insane! I had a Corvette that I financed $25K on at 0% and my payment was in the neighborhood of $600. I thought that was a ton of money in 2004! I have neighbors who don’t have two nickels to rub together who go out and lease a new car when they get to the point that they need to replace tires because they don’t have the $$$ to buy new tires. This is absolutely insane.
On a different yet related topic, I found a very nice brand new townhome in Redondo Beach up here in LA. Really nicely done Med style, high quality finish materials (granite, travertine, crown molding, etc). It was completed and originally listed in Sep 07 for $859K, now reduced to $829K. Agent claims the seller/builder will refund $$$ to match sales price with last unit sold (i.e buy now for $829K and if the last of the ten units sells for $759K, I would get $70K back). Sounds too good to be true…so we know the adage.
Do you think I’d have a crack at a deal at a $750K offer? it’s blocks from the beach, good schools for LA, etc…
Also, we’re dealing with only being able to put about $100K down, are there still loan products out there to help me without burying me?
-
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.