It all depends on how much capital gain you are getting from the sale. Someone closer to the 250K for single and 500K for a couple limits should probably sell. Someone that has about 50K worth of gain after paying commission/closing should probably hold if good tennant in place. I have about 125K of capital gain and down to 6 months left before my home owners exemption expires. I will probably hold for now. It does good as a rental and I’m not seeing a better return on the money elsewhere.