I won’t bother with telling you to wait at least until the fall since other have and it’s not registering. We have a classic case of “my wife wants” and without a happy wife there is no happy life.
If it’s just about schools then find out the specific schools they will attend (district websites usually have maps on the internet, I’ve found many owners and realtors to be incorrect or not aware of planned changes). You can check their academic scores on the state website and can see demographic specifics, college acceptance rates, etc. and finally you can visit those schools in person.
I think you are going to find it will be close to a tie. Those two areas are both in the top tier of the county as far as schools go. This is very much like having a Mercedes vs BMW debate, their both great, it just comes down to preference.
