At the same time, you cannot claim adverse possion against him. I’m not an attny but it seems strange to bring quiet title into this. As I see it, you have a legal easement for this roadway and he is interferring with that enjoyment. And, there are other folks that share the same easement.
Again, I think this is a civil enforcement matter not a new issue as to who holds title. Does that make sense? What about a restraining order against him?
Seems like all grantees to that easement need to band together and issue a letter communicating to the dick to keep off the easement and no further harrassment.
I would also think the prescrptive easement by the old people would help you as it shows the good use of the land longer than you have had your paid easement.
This is where the legal fees should go. Am I missing something?
Ok, so are you planning on suing for damages to repair the road plus personal stuff?