Again, guessing, .. any damages awarded will be very hard to collect from this guy. With that in mind, do you have and real damages short of the access to the road? Like $100k documented medical bills. Punitive is expensive to litigate and I doubt applicable in this situation.
So,if you don’t have any major damages and just want to spank him using the punitive argument I would regroup and just go for the court order for him to stop blocking your road. That’s it.
Going pro-per sounds like an option with all of your evidence. I would pay 1-2 hr atty consult for strategy.
Ask atty for estimate to prepare this for trial with hopes of summery judgement prior to full trial. No discovery, title searches, etc. Just more knowledge for you at this point.
But first, I would pay for the final demand letter on atty letterhead before doing anything else.
