We used Carmel Valley Collision on Sorrento Valley Rd three times in the past 3 years (yep, we have a teenage driver who did damage twice, and then another, unrelated, teenage driver scraped one of our cars in a parking lot). We’ve been very happy with their prices and quality of work. Small, un-fancy shop run by a guy who definitely takes pride in his work. http://www.carmelvalleycollision.com/