[quote=patb] . . . They may appeal into the court of appeals, but, it’s binding now on all the 62 supreme courts.[/quote]

patb, I don’t know how the court hierarchy is structured in NY, but, based on your post, I don’t see how one “Supreme” court’s decision in one county in NY could be binding upon other judges in the same state. Is the opinion published? Acc to your post, it hasn’t even been appealed yet. Defendants MERS (and lender) have a right of appeal and they may very well do so. It sounds like the “fat lady” has not yet sung on this one.