I hear ya. Many moons ago when I lived in Jacksonville, FL I tried that site. IIRC there were about 9,000 female profiles on the site. I did a simple search based on three criteria that I considered personally important to me:
1. College degree
2. Non-smoker
3. No children from a previous relationship
Those three criteria reduced the pool from over 9,000 down to 3 – and non of the three had a picture 😉