I think we are talking about the same person sdr. She handles mechanics well and yoru implication is that indeed she is to “nice” of a personality that she cannot impose her will on clients.

I am not sure that this characterizes her as a poor listing agent. Perhaps in your opinion it does but then again you said or implied as I am to lazy to backtrack the thread that the real work for a GOOD listing agent does not begin until escrow starts.

Perhaps we are simply arguing semantics here. Also because you were able to convince your client that selling at price X is a good move does by no means imply that you would have been able to convince her client to sell at price X.

Correct me if I am wrong but you are saying that she is not a quality agent because she could not talk her clients into selling at price X.

To me unless you have had a crack at talking to her clients, your statement is speculative. Perhaps there are cases where she did not perform well that you have experienced with her.

What I am saying is that your success with your clients does not preclude anything to do with her and her clients.