Home › Forums › Other › How does one start a petition drive for a CA state “tax reform” in lieu of SALT caps?
- This topic has 25 replies, 9 voices, and was last updated 6 years, 8 months ago by
Coronita.
-
AuthorPosts
-
December 20, 2017 at 5:41 AM #22482December 20, 2017 at 6:24 AM #808796
SK in CV
ParticipantI think you skipped a step in your explanation. The qualifying charitable organizations should be organizations that are already getting state funding. Like schools. Arizona has some that aren’t currently funded by the state (like private schools, whose funding I personally strongly oppose, and would hate to see California include them in qualifying organizations). But most of the organizations are things the state is either already funding or reasonably could fund. I do not know whether the state reduces funding based on the amount of direct contributions, but there are some credits that are limited in total dollar amount.
December 20, 2017 at 6:53 AM #808797Coronita
Participant[quote=SK in CV]I think you skipped a step in your explanation. The qualifying charitable organizations should be organizations that are already getting state funding. Like schools. Arizona has some that aren’t currently funded by the state (like private schools, whose funding I personally strongly oppose, and would hate to see California include them in qualifying organizations). But most of the organizations are things the state is either already funding or reasonably could fund. I do not know whether the state reduces funding based on the amount of direct contributions, but there are some credits that are limited in total dollar amount.[/quote]
Fair enough…. Anyway, this is just a big game….Consider it a hobby, outside of when I’m driving. I just think it’s interesting how people’s fortunes can change simply by a few line item changes.
A few weeks ago, a few folks bent out of shape concerning the tax reform was pondering could could the state strike back at these tax reforms….
In principle, here’s a strategy that might work. Where are all you folks that want to effect change and want CA to screw the fed back? Are you going to help ask our state representatives to do something? SK is in Arizona, so his state already does something about it… He’s excused 🙂
December 20, 2017 at 7:09 AM #808798SK in CV
ParticipantIf I was a state legislator, I wouldn’t frame it as screwing the fed. It’s benefitting the taxpayers of California without costing the state any revenue, or costing any currently funded organization. Taxpayers who are tax aware can save some money. Tax advisors score.
December 20, 2017 at 7:09 AM #808799spdrun
ParticipantHow to make sure that the money donated to charity is distributed equitably? What if United Way gets 90% of the donations and ends up with money it can’t use, and Podunk Unified School District ends up with zippo squat?
Would “approved” charities have to spend their money in a specific way or in specific (and multiple) places to guarantee that it’s distributed throughout the state?
December 20, 2017 at 7:48 AM #808800SK in CV
ParticipantGive the money directly to the school district or even school. That’s how AZ does it. The tax credit form requires that you specify the school or school district. In fact, you can even specify the program within the school to get the funds. I send $400 (almost) directly to my niece’s classroom. She gets to have aids in her 16 kid, all non-verbal, special ed classroom because of the money she raises. I get credit exactly (for me anyway, there are limitations) like an estimated tax payment on my AZ return and a charitable deduction on my federal return.
December 20, 2017 at 8:15 AM #808802spdrun
ParticipantWhat if everyone donates to school districts in San Francisco but very few donate to districts in Stockton?
December 20, 2017 at 8:45 AM #808803outtamojo
Participant[quote=flu][quote=SK in CV]I think you skipped a step in your explanation. The qualifying charitable organizations should be organizations that are already getting state funding. Like schools. Arizona has some that aren’t currently funded by the state (like private schools, whose funding I personally strongly oppose, and would hate to see California include them in qualifying organizations). But most of the organizations are things the state is either already funding or reasonably could fund. I do not know whether the state reduces funding based on the amount of direct contributions, but there are some credits that are limited in total dollar amount.[/quote]
Fair enough…. Anyway, this is just a big game….Consider it a hobby, outside of when I’m driving. I just think it’s interesting how people’s fortunes can change simply by a few line item changes.
A few weeks ago, a few folks bent out of shape concerning the tax reform was pondering could could the state strike back at these tax reforms….
In principle, here’s a strategy that might work. Where are all you folks that want to effect change and want CA to screw the fed back? Are you going to help ask our state representatives to do something? SK is in Arizona, so his state already does something about it… He’s excused :)[/quote]
Imo the best way to screw back is to get folks more riled up about their lies and vote them out of office #whereismyraise
December 20, 2017 at 9:40 AM #808804livinincali
Participant[quote=spdrun]What if everyone donates to school districts in San Francisco but very few donate to districts in Stockton?[/quote]
That’s why the credits would need to be limited to some dollar amount like Arizona does. Obviously the state still needs to receive money and allocate to various programs and services throughout the state. It could never function if everyone were allowed to dictate what their tax dollars are used for. At best maybe you could convert 10% of the states income tax revenue into charitable contributions for federal tax purposes before you start running into problems.
I just don’t really see the path that high cost of living/high tax state can take to to relieve the sting of this tax bill. It you were itemizing your taxes because of high state tax and mortgage interest deduction and you weren’t already in AMT land you’re getting monkey hammered by this. If you weren’t then it’s marginally better.
In summary upper middle income tax payers in the West and Northeast are getting hosed to give the average middle income american $50-100 extra per month. The corporate tax breaks are going to add $150 billion a year in deficits.
The reality was that upper income tax payers are where the money is so any tax reform was going to hit them the hardest. Under a Clinton presidency maybe the truly wealthy wouldn’t have gotten as much of a break and the middle class american might has gotten more, but there’ no way upper middle income taxpayers weren’t going to pay for it in the end.
December 20, 2017 at 10:14 AM #808805Coronita
Participant[quote=SK in CV]If I was a state legislator, I wouldn’t frame it as screwing the fed. It’s benefitting the taxpayers of California without costing the state any revenue, or costing any currently funded organization. Taxpayers who are tax aware can save some money. Tax advisors score.[/quote]
Yes! Exactly.. it’s all is how the message is delivered. You don’t want to be directly confrontational with the fed.
December 20, 2017 at 10:18 AM #808806Coronita
Participant[quote=SK in CV]Give the money directly to the school district or even school. That’s how AZ does it. The tax credit form requires that you specify the school or school district. In fact, you can even specify the program within the school to get the funds. I send $400 (almost) directly to my niece’s classroom. She gets to have aids in her 16 kid, all non-verbal, special ed classroom because of the money she raises. I get credit exactly (for me anyway, there are limitations) like an estimated tax payment on my AZ return and a charitable deduction on my federal return.[/quote]
Another good point. I stopped donating directly to my school district’s general pool fund. I make my donations directly to the specific school’s science and grade teachers classroom, complete with receipt….need a new computer to run the latest simple machine tool? done…. Just make sure you get a nice receipt.
December 20, 2017 at 10:20 AM #808807Coronita
ParticipantUsually the school district then tries to adjust money from the general donation pool fund and gives more to the schools that have less contribution.
December 20, 2017 at 10:22 AM #808808scaredyclassic
Participanti cant figure out if im going to pay more tax. we get hit pretty hard by AMT and the,sample calculators dont acct for that.
on the bright side, if this,depresses real estate prices, maybe my kud will be better able to buy.
December 20, 2017 at 10:59 AM #808809Coronita
ParticipantWell, time to make my annual 529 contributions. Lol..m.
December 23, 2017 at 8:41 AM #808841Coronita
ParticipantLooks like some politicians have caught on…. We’ll see if it sticks next year.
De León, who also is running for U.S. Senate, said the state Senate is working with law professors at UCLA, UC Davis and the University of Chicago to develop the legislation.
Ideas being considered, according to a de León spokesman, include:
Reducing state personal income taxes through a tax credit program and offsetting that amount through payroll taxes.
Allowing individuals to make voluntary gifts to the state of California, which would be deductible as a charitable donation under federal law. The deduction for the donated amount would replace the state and local tax deduction. -
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.