Home › Forums › Financial Markets/Economics › Who needs wall street innovation
- This topic has 90 replies, 11 voices, and was last updated 15 years ago by patb.
-
AuthorPosts
-
November 4, 2009 at 9:34 AM #477486November 4, 2009 at 11:16 AM #477916dbapigParticipant
[quote=dbapig][quote=afx114]Kiva.org is innovation.[/quote]
True but is it really a Wall Street innovation or Tech innovation? It’s more of a tech innovation, aka internet.
You cannot really say ‘Wall Street’ and ‘Kiva’ in the same sentence.[/quote]
Another thought. Kiva exists for the good of the poor in 3rd world, and for us more fortunate to feel good about doing good.
What can you say about Wall Street?
Let’s not drag the good name Kiva into the pit of Wall Street…
November 4, 2009 at 11:16 AM #477550dbapigParticipant[quote=dbapig][quote=afx114]Kiva.org is innovation.[/quote]
True but is it really a Wall Street innovation or Tech innovation? It’s more of a tech innovation, aka internet.
You cannot really say ‘Wall Street’ and ‘Kiva’ in the same sentence.[/quote]
Another thought. Kiva exists for the good of the poor in 3rd world, and for us more fortunate to feel good about doing good.
What can you say about Wall Street?
Let’s not drag the good name Kiva into the pit of Wall Street…
November 4, 2009 at 11:16 AM #478218dbapigParticipant[quote=dbapig][quote=afx114]Kiva.org is innovation.[/quote]
True but is it really a Wall Street innovation or Tech innovation? It’s more of a tech innovation, aka internet.
You cannot really say ‘Wall Street’ and ‘Kiva’ in the same sentence.[/quote]
Another thought. Kiva exists for the good of the poor in 3rd world, and for us more fortunate to feel good about doing good.
What can you say about Wall Street?
Let’s not drag the good name Kiva into the pit of Wall Street…
November 4, 2009 at 11:16 AM #477997dbapigParticipant[quote=dbapig][quote=afx114]Kiva.org is innovation.[/quote]
True but is it really a Wall Street innovation or Tech innovation? It’s more of a tech innovation, aka internet.
You cannot really say ‘Wall Street’ and ‘Kiva’ in the same sentence.[/quote]
Another thought. Kiva exists for the good of the poor in 3rd world, and for us more fortunate to feel good about doing good.
What can you say about Wall Street?
Let’s not drag the good name Kiva into the pit of Wall Street…
November 4, 2009 at 11:16 AM #477379dbapigParticipant[quote=dbapig][quote=afx114]Kiva.org is innovation.[/quote]
True but is it really a Wall Street innovation or Tech innovation? It’s more of a tech innovation, aka internet.
You cannot really say ‘Wall Street’ and ‘Kiva’ in the same sentence.[/quote]
Another thought. Kiva exists for the good of the poor in 3rd world, and for us more fortunate to feel good about doing good.
What can you say about Wall Street?
Let’s not drag the good name Kiva into the pit of Wall Street…
November 4, 2009 at 11:31 AM #477926daveljParticipantI don’t have a problem with financial innovation, per se. None of the following were “bad” products for the first several years of their existences: securitized mortgages, credit default swaps, option ARMs, etc.
The problem is that the nature of Wall Street is to push every innovation (which may be perfectly useful on a limited scale) to the point that it starts to fail. And recently we had a whole bunch of these pushed to the edge and failing all at the same time.
A simple “30-year fixed-rate mortgage” was once considered a major financial innovation. Would it be better if we eliminated mortgages (or credit cards?) altogether? I think not.
I don’t think the problem is innovation. The problem is the degree to which these innovations are foisted upon folks who should have no exposure to them.
November 4, 2009 at 11:31 AM #478227daveljParticipantI don’t have a problem with financial innovation, per se. None of the following were “bad” products for the first several years of their existences: securitized mortgages, credit default swaps, option ARMs, etc.
The problem is that the nature of Wall Street is to push every innovation (which may be perfectly useful on a limited scale) to the point that it starts to fail. And recently we had a whole bunch of these pushed to the edge and failing all at the same time.
A simple “30-year fixed-rate mortgage” was once considered a major financial innovation. Would it be better if we eliminated mortgages (or credit cards?) altogether? I think not.
I don’t think the problem is innovation. The problem is the degree to which these innovations are foisted upon folks who should have no exposure to them.
November 4, 2009 at 11:31 AM #477560daveljParticipantI don’t have a problem with financial innovation, per se. None of the following were “bad” products for the first several years of their existences: securitized mortgages, credit default swaps, option ARMs, etc.
The problem is that the nature of Wall Street is to push every innovation (which may be perfectly useful on a limited scale) to the point that it starts to fail. And recently we had a whole bunch of these pushed to the edge and failing all at the same time.
A simple “30-year fixed-rate mortgage” was once considered a major financial innovation. Would it be better if we eliminated mortgages (or credit cards?) altogether? I think not.
I don’t think the problem is innovation. The problem is the degree to which these innovations are foisted upon folks who should have no exposure to them.
November 4, 2009 at 11:31 AM #477389daveljParticipantI don’t have a problem with financial innovation, per se. None of the following were “bad” products for the first several years of their existences: securitized mortgages, credit default swaps, option ARMs, etc.
The problem is that the nature of Wall Street is to push every innovation (which may be perfectly useful on a limited scale) to the point that it starts to fail. And recently we had a whole bunch of these pushed to the edge and failing all at the same time.
A simple “30-year fixed-rate mortgage” was once considered a major financial innovation. Would it be better if we eliminated mortgages (or credit cards?) altogether? I think not.
I don’t think the problem is innovation. The problem is the degree to which these innovations are foisted upon folks who should have no exposure to them.
November 4, 2009 at 11:31 AM #478007daveljParticipantI don’t have a problem with financial innovation, per se. None of the following were “bad” products for the first several years of their existences: securitized mortgages, credit default swaps, option ARMs, etc.
The problem is that the nature of Wall Street is to push every innovation (which may be perfectly useful on a limited scale) to the point that it starts to fail. And recently we had a whole bunch of these pushed to the edge and failing all at the same time.
A simple “30-year fixed-rate mortgage” was once considered a major financial innovation. Would it be better if we eliminated mortgages (or credit cards?) altogether? I think not.
I don’t think the problem is innovation. The problem is the degree to which these innovations are foisted upon folks who should have no exposure to them.
November 4, 2009 at 1:40 PM #478353patbParticipant[quote=briansd1]Credit innovation is just a way to borrow from the future in a way that makes it seem less painful today.
People used to buy cars with cash savings. Then they could buy cars with 20% down. Then they bought cars with zero down. Then they leased cars with residual value at the end of the lease.
Consumption/production gets front-loaded but the debts need to be paid back some way, somehow, in the future.
Wall Street “earned” up-front commissions on making credit available so they don’t care if the debt is ever paid back. The onus will be on the government to bailout the system.
We all end-up in debt servitude where all of our income goes to service debt and to pay for services that we think we need.[/quote]
i still buy cars with cash or a 6 month note
November 4, 2009 at 1:40 PM #477683patbParticipant[quote=briansd1]Credit innovation is just a way to borrow from the future in a way that makes it seem less painful today.
People used to buy cars with cash savings. Then they could buy cars with 20% down. Then they bought cars with zero down. Then they leased cars with residual value at the end of the lease.
Consumption/production gets front-loaded but the debts need to be paid back some way, somehow, in the future.
Wall Street “earned” up-front commissions on making credit available so they don’t care if the debt is ever paid back. The onus will be on the government to bailout the system.
We all end-up in debt servitude where all of our income goes to service debt and to pay for services that we think we need.[/quote]
i still buy cars with cash or a 6 month note
November 4, 2009 at 1:40 PM #478050patbParticipant[quote=briansd1]Credit innovation is just a way to borrow from the future in a way that makes it seem less painful today.
People used to buy cars with cash savings. Then they could buy cars with 20% down. Then they bought cars with zero down. Then they leased cars with residual value at the end of the lease.
Consumption/production gets front-loaded but the debts need to be paid back some way, somehow, in the future.
Wall Street “earned” up-front commissions on making credit available so they don’t care if the debt is ever paid back. The onus will be on the government to bailout the system.
We all end-up in debt servitude where all of our income goes to service debt and to pay for services that we think we need.[/quote]
i still buy cars with cash or a 6 month note
November 4, 2009 at 1:40 PM #477513patbParticipant[quote=briansd1]Credit innovation is just a way to borrow from the future in a way that makes it seem less painful today.
People used to buy cars with cash savings. Then they could buy cars with 20% down. Then they bought cars with zero down. Then they leased cars with residual value at the end of the lease.
Consumption/production gets front-loaded but the debts need to be paid back some way, somehow, in the future.
Wall Street “earned” up-front commissions on making credit available so they don’t care if the debt is ever paid back. The onus will be on the government to bailout the system.
We all end-up in debt servitude where all of our income goes to service debt and to pay for services that we think we need.[/quote]
i still buy cars with cash or a 6 month note
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.