- This topic has 61 replies, 22 voices, and was last updated 11 years, 11 months ago by davelj.
-
AuthorPosts
-
December 2, 2012 at 8:13 PM #20339December 2, 2012 at 8:34 PM #755656outtamojoParticipant
These guys just don’t get it- college is for meeting chicks.
December 2, 2012 at 10:47 PM #755666zkParticipantI don’t find this article convincing at all.
While I agree that a young adult might learn more “out in the world” than at college, I’m not convinced that their job and financial prospects aren’t better if they go to college.
For every Gates, Dell, or Zuckerberg there are a thousand Vincent Chus. Never heard of Vincent Chu? Of course not. He and thousands of other “mavericks” dropped out of or never went to college, and never hit it big with an app or anything else. Now they work at The Gap to pay the bills, and they’re hoping to get into management some day.
When I was in high school (or college, I don’t remember – either way, it was at least 30 years ago) one of my teachers said that college wasn’t so much to learn things as to show prospective employers that you could do what it took to get into and then get through college (and, by extension, that you might have what it takes to do whatever job they were offering). Whether that’s a good measuring stick or not is certainly debatable. The point is that, whether you learn anything useful or not, a college degree does improve your marketability as a prospective employee.
A college degree is certainly not a golden ticket. In fact, it’s even less of a golden ticket than it was a decade or two ago. But it still (imho) offers the best chance of a decent-paying job.
Plus it’s a great place to meet chicks.
December 2, 2012 at 10:50 PM #755663CoronitaParticipantThere’s one big difference.
The very tiny percentage of these people described in this article that dropped out of college are very very intelligent people who didn’t need to go to college…
Most americans aren’t like that.
December 2, 2012 at 10:51 PM #755667scaredyclassicParticipantand ponder existence.
December 3, 2012 at 8:12 AM #755674SK in CVParticipant[quote=zk]I don’t find this article convincing at all.
While I agree that a young adult might learn more “out in the world” than at college, I’m not convinced that their job and financial prospects aren’t better if they go to college.
For every Gates, Dell, or Zuckerberg there are a thousand Vincent Chus. Never heard of Vincent Chu? Of course not. He and thousands of other “mavericks” dropped out of or never went to college, and never hit it big with an app or anything else. Now they work at The Gap to pay the bills, and they’re hoping to get into management some day.
Plus it’s a great place to meet chicks.[/quote]
I agree with this. College isn’t for everyone, but it’s almost always better to have that degree than not have it.
Back in the old days, when I was in college, I had a friend who started and then dropped out. He had a part time job delivering lost luggage at the airport. Made tips and a little more than min wage. Then the guy who owned the company got busted for stealing shit out of the suitcases and the guy at the airport who was in charge of the operation offered him the contract because he was the 2nd in command. He was pretty rich compared to the rest of us. was 20 years old and making probably $22K a year plus tips. Owned a couple vans, had employees. Paid his own rent, funded his IRA every year, bought a porsche (ok, it was a 914, but it still said porsche on the insignia).
Ten years later, Charlie was still making $22K a year, had 3 van payments to make and was stressed beyond belief. Expenses went up and he had to withdraw his IRA money just to make ends meet. He was working 50+ hours a week and no time to meet any women. He wanted to do something else but didn’t have any experience. and no degree. At 32, he caught some weird virus and died.
Times might be a little different now. But not that different.
December 3, 2012 at 8:40 AM #755677bearishgurlParticipantFT college is the right thing to do for recent HS grads IF:
-they don’t have any kids to support (if they do, then part-time college should be considered);
-they are not entering the military;
-they are in good enough health to complete all four years;
-they will never have to borrow to enroll or stay in college;
-they know what they want to major in;
-and, their major of choice is one in which they can easily get hired into FT employment (w/benefits) … even if they have to relocate to do so.
Otherwise, it is huge waste of time and money and there is little chance of the student actually graduating with a bachelor’s degree, IMO.
If the recent HS grad just wants to find “chicks” or get an MRS degree, it’s MUCH cheaper to join match.com and/or hang out with their former HS “homies” while living in a parent’s back bdrm and working at the Gap.
December 3, 2012 at 8:51 AM #755679meadandaleParticipant[quote=flu]There’s one big difference.
The very tiny percentage of these people described in this article that dropped out of college are very very intelligent people who didn’t need to go to college…
Most americans aren’t like that.[/quote]
^^^ This
The lazy, latte sipping hipsters living in their parent’s basement complaining about getting a 40 hr/wk job aren’t going to be the next Steve Jobs or Mark Z.
The one thing all of the people mentioned in the article all have in common? They are all type A personalities and would have been successful in any businesses INCLUDING tech…with or without college.
December 3, 2012 at 8:57 AM #755680NotCrankyParticipantI think I will start a website/movement called
“The Wise Slacker”. So many people are so dumb at slacking, when potentially, it is a smart thing to do.December 3, 2012 at 9:03 AM #755681no_such_realityParticipantBG, you just described the primary problem with our education system.
It used to be a job training program.
It’s now shifted to education for education sake. I can see some potential usefulness of italian cultural studies. Slightly more limited for italian languange or italian literature.
http://www.italian.ucla.edu/programs/grad.html
But really, apply this across virtually any culture.
I’m not opposed to education, but I truely believe, 99% of us, need an education in practical skills to allow us to have productive jobs and should reserve the enrichment education to a more modest level of expense.
And when we decide to truely get serious about education, we’ll separate the professional sports farm teams from the colleges.
December 3, 2012 at 10:19 AM #755683CoronitaParticipant[quote=meadandale][quote=flu]There’s one big difference.
The very tiny percentage of these people described in this article that dropped out of college are very very intelligent people who didn’t need to go to college…
Most americans aren’t like that.[/quote]
^^^ This
The lazy, latte sipping hipsters living in their parent’s basement complaining about getting a 40 hr/wk job aren’t going to be the next Steve Jobs or Mark Z.
The one thing all of the people mentioned in the article all have in common? They are all type A personalities and would have been successful in any businesses INCLUDING tech…with or without college.[/quote]
Nope. But they are the ones that most likely voted for prop 30…Well, because they don’t have to pay for it.
December 3, 2012 at 10:53 AM #755684Rich ToscanoKeymaster[quote=flu]
Nope. But they are the ones that most likely voted for prop 30…Well, because they don’t have to pay for it.[/quote]Threadjack alert! Everyone go back to the conversation about the value of college education, nothing to see here…
December 3, 2012 at 10:57 AM #755685spdrunParticipantCollege is useful for meeting PEOPLE (not just chicks). Note that Zuckerberg laid the initial groundwork for FB while at college, and probably met some connections that were useful to him there as well.
It’s also sad that the US puts a lot of emphasis on success in business, but not so much on basic scientific/medical research, non-I.T. engineering, and academic careers anymore. The world doesn’t start and end at I.T. entrepreneurship despite what some people may think. It’s a problem that the US lags behind the rest of the world in scientific research and in basic infrastructure.
December 3, 2012 at 11:17 AM #755687CoronitaParticipant.
December 3, 2012 at 12:42 PM #755693Diego MamaniParticipant[quote=SK in CV]Then the guy who owned the company got busted for stealing shit out of the suitcases and the guy at the airport who was in charge of the operation offered him the contract because he was the 2nd in command. He was pretty rich compared to the rest of us. was 20 years old and making probably $22K a year plus tips. Owned a couple vans, had employees. Paid his own rent, funded his IRA every year, bought a porsche (ok, it was a 914, but it still said porsche on the insignia).[/quote]
Great story SK. I wonder how that business works. A few years back an airline misplaced one of my suitcases. The airline found the suitcase the next day and had it delivered to my house. I was very surprised by the delivery: it took place quite late at night, and the delivery guy was a well-dressed gentleman in his late 50s or early 60s, driving a late model Lexus SUV.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.