- This topic has 420 replies, 21 voices, and was last updated 16 years, 9 months ago by
PCinSD.
-
AuthorPosts
-
December 6, 2008 at 3:40 PM #312781December 6, 2008 at 7:59 PM #312379
kewp
Participant[quote=temeculaguy]
One other thing to worry about, if they box it, then they probably ferment in steel. Go old school until the research narrows it down, because those healthy 80 year old smokers in france didn’t drink steel fermented boxed wine. It may end up being the naps anyway, just drink what you like.[/quote]
Thanks temeculaguy!
Do you see any problem with just recorking a bottle after having a glass or two a night?
December 6, 2008 at 7:59 PM #312735kewp
Participant[quote=temeculaguy]
One other thing to worry about, if they box it, then they probably ferment in steel. Go old school until the research narrows it down, because those healthy 80 year old smokers in france didn’t drink steel fermented boxed wine. It may end up being the naps anyway, just drink what you like.[/quote]
Thanks temeculaguy!
Do you see any problem with just recorking a bottle after having a glass or two a night?
December 6, 2008 at 7:59 PM #312766kewp
Participant[quote=temeculaguy]
One other thing to worry about, if they box it, then they probably ferment in steel. Go old school until the research narrows it down, because those healthy 80 year old smokers in france didn’t drink steel fermented boxed wine. It may end up being the naps anyway, just drink what you like.[/quote]
Thanks temeculaguy!
Do you see any problem with just recorking a bottle after having a glass or two a night?
December 6, 2008 at 7:59 PM #312788kewp
Participant[quote=temeculaguy]
One other thing to worry about, if they box it, then they probably ferment in steel. Go old school until the research narrows it down, because those healthy 80 year old smokers in france didn’t drink steel fermented boxed wine. It may end up being the naps anyway, just drink what you like.[/quote]
Thanks temeculaguy!
Do you see any problem with just recorking a bottle after having a glass or two a night?
December 6, 2008 at 7:59 PM #312857kewp
Participant[quote=temeculaguy]
One other thing to worry about, if they box it, then they probably ferment in steel. Go old school until the research narrows it down, because those healthy 80 year old smokers in france didn’t drink steel fermented boxed wine. It may end up being the naps anyway, just drink what you like.[/quote]
Thanks temeculaguy!
Do you see any problem with just recorking a bottle after having a glass or two a night?
December 6, 2008 at 11:47 PM #312423
barnaby33ParticipantFor some really cheap stuff, corking it and putting it back doesn’t work. Of course if its that cheap, why bother.
Mostly if you are going to drink it over a 3-4 day period thats what I do. Sure you get some oxidation, but its not enough to ruin most wine. If it is, maybe you should buy something else.
December 6, 2008 at 11:47 PM #312780
barnaby33ParticipantFor some really cheap stuff, corking it and putting it back doesn’t work. Of course if its that cheap, why bother.
Mostly if you are going to drink it over a 3-4 day period thats what I do. Sure you get some oxidation, but its not enough to ruin most wine. If it is, maybe you should buy something else.
December 6, 2008 at 11:47 PM #312812
barnaby33ParticipantFor some really cheap stuff, corking it and putting it back doesn’t work. Of course if its that cheap, why bother.
Mostly if you are going to drink it over a 3-4 day period thats what I do. Sure you get some oxidation, but its not enough to ruin most wine. If it is, maybe you should buy something else.
December 6, 2008 at 11:47 PM #312834
barnaby33ParticipantFor some really cheap stuff, corking it and putting it back doesn’t work. Of course if its that cheap, why bother.
Mostly if you are going to drink it over a 3-4 day period thats what I do. Sure you get some oxidation, but its not enough to ruin most wine. If it is, maybe you should buy something else.
December 6, 2008 at 11:47 PM #312901
barnaby33ParticipantFor some really cheap stuff, corking it and putting it back doesn’t work. Of course if its that cheap, why bother.
Mostly if you are going to drink it over a 3-4 day period thats what I do. Sure you get some oxidation, but its not enough to ruin most wine. If it is, maybe you should buy something else.
December 7, 2008 at 11:10 AM #312513george
ParticipantBarnaby, I see it differently. In my experience, the negative sensory impact of oxidation has nothing to do with the initial quality of the wine. Personally, I am much more concerned about damaging an expensive wine, than a cheap one. What’s the point in paying a lot for an excellent wine only to drink it in a condition that the winemaker would never sell it in? I find the smell and taste of oxidation is more noticable in white wines. I particularly notice it the light bodied whites. However, I find that most wines will be fine for a couple days. If you you have an unfinished bottle of red you could put it in the fridge and then pull it back out a few hours before your going to drink from it again. Oxidation is a chemical reaction so it slows down at lower temperatures. Most people (like my wife) don’t know what an mildly oxidized wine smells or tastes like, they just know the wine tastes lousy. If the wine smells or tastes even remotely like Sherry, it’s oxidized. Unfortunately, once you learn to indentify oxidation (via taste/smell) it’s impossible to ignore it.
December 7, 2008 at 11:10 AM #312870george
ParticipantBarnaby, I see it differently. In my experience, the negative sensory impact of oxidation has nothing to do with the initial quality of the wine. Personally, I am much more concerned about damaging an expensive wine, than a cheap one. What’s the point in paying a lot for an excellent wine only to drink it in a condition that the winemaker would never sell it in? I find the smell and taste of oxidation is more noticable in white wines. I particularly notice it the light bodied whites. However, I find that most wines will be fine for a couple days. If you you have an unfinished bottle of red you could put it in the fridge and then pull it back out a few hours before your going to drink from it again. Oxidation is a chemical reaction so it slows down at lower temperatures. Most people (like my wife) don’t know what an mildly oxidized wine smells or tastes like, they just know the wine tastes lousy. If the wine smells or tastes even remotely like Sherry, it’s oxidized. Unfortunately, once you learn to indentify oxidation (via taste/smell) it’s impossible to ignore it.
December 7, 2008 at 11:10 AM #312902george
ParticipantBarnaby, I see it differently. In my experience, the negative sensory impact of oxidation has nothing to do with the initial quality of the wine. Personally, I am much more concerned about damaging an expensive wine, than a cheap one. What’s the point in paying a lot for an excellent wine only to drink it in a condition that the winemaker would never sell it in? I find the smell and taste of oxidation is more noticable in white wines. I particularly notice it the light bodied whites. However, I find that most wines will be fine for a couple days. If you you have an unfinished bottle of red you could put it in the fridge and then pull it back out a few hours before your going to drink from it again. Oxidation is a chemical reaction so it slows down at lower temperatures. Most people (like my wife) don’t know what an mildly oxidized wine smells or tastes like, they just know the wine tastes lousy. If the wine smells or tastes even remotely like Sherry, it’s oxidized. Unfortunately, once you learn to indentify oxidation (via taste/smell) it’s impossible to ignore it.
December 7, 2008 at 11:10 AM #312924george
ParticipantBarnaby, I see it differently. In my experience, the negative sensory impact of oxidation has nothing to do with the initial quality of the wine. Personally, I am much more concerned about damaging an expensive wine, than a cheap one. What’s the point in paying a lot for an excellent wine only to drink it in a condition that the winemaker would never sell it in? I find the smell and taste of oxidation is more noticable in white wines. I particularly notice it the light bodied whites. However, I find that most wines will be fine for a couple days. If you you have an unfinished bottle of red you could put it in the fridge and then pull it back out a few hours before your going to drink from it again. Oxidation is a chemical reaction so it slows down at lower temperatures. Most people (like my wife) don’t know what an mildly oxidized wine smells or tastes like, they just know the wine tastes lousy. If the wine smells or tastes even remotely like Sherry, it’s oxidized. Unfortunately, once you learn to indentify oxidation (via taste/smell) it’s impossible to ignore it.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
