Point Loma reducing a little

[an]

[quote=CA renter]
BG is right about custom vs. tract homes. In general, a custom home will hold it’s value/appreciate more than a tract home, all else being equal.[/quote]
Do you have data behind this? Not trying to pick on you, just want to know if this is your opinion or it is in-fact a reality. I think to have a more apple to apple comparison between custom vs tract, they must be in the same zip code, build around the same year, similar sq-ft for house AND lot. I know this is probably a hard if not impossible exercise, but it help prove your statement “all else being equal”.

[quote=CA renter]The difference between the MH home and the LJ home you’ve linked above is that there are a number of people who seek out older, “historical” custom homes. Just anecdotal, but a lot of these people tend to be DINKS and/or people with a lot of money who like to buy something architecturally unique and aesthetically pleasing.

While newer homes might need less maintenance, work better for families, and be in “better” school districts (the reasons why most people seek out the newer tract homes), there is nothing unique or beautiful about them, IMHO. You get a lot of young families in tract homes, and these buyers tend to be the weakest buyers, so they are more prone to financial distress, IMHO.

FWIW, I’m a sucker for older, custom homes, so have to admit my bias. 😉 Seriously, since we’re looking for a custom home ourselves, I can assure you that the competition is fierce, and lots of these buyers have tons of cash.[/quote]
I wonder if it has something to do with generational as well. Personally, I look at that MH home and I see nothing attractive about it. There’s a difference between a beautiful custom home in RSF vs these 1500 sq-ft early-mid century custom homes in my eyes. 1500 sq-ft my be huge 50-90 years ago, but it’s tiny in today’s standard.

[sdrealtor]

My experience has been that custom homes dont necessarily hold value better. They tend to be built more specific to the desires of the original owner and become functionally obsellete quicker. They also tend to be more expensive and that in and of itself is detrimental to a higher appreciation rate. Its all about location. Beach houses appreciated more and happen to be mostly custom builds. If they threw tracts on oceanfront lots in the 60’s and 70’s you would see higher appreciation also

[sdrealtor]

My experience has been that custom homes dont necessarily hold value better. They tend to be built more specific to the desires of the original owner and become functionally obsellete quicker. They also tend to be more expensive and that in and of itself is detrimental to a higher appreciation rate. Its all about location. Beach houses appreciated more and happen to be mostly custom builds. If they threw tracts on oceanfront lots in the 60’s and 70’s you would see higher appreciation also

[sdrealtor]

My experience has been that custom homes dont necessarily hold value better. They tend to be built more specific to the desires of the original owner and become functionally obsellete quicker. They also tend to be more expensive and that in and of itself is detrimental to a higher appreciation rate. Its all about location. Beach houses appreciated more and happen to be mostly custom builds. If they threw tracts on oceanfront lots in the 60’s and 70’s you would see higher appreciation also

[sdrealtor]

My experience has been that custom homes dont necessarily hold value better. They tend to be built more specific to the desires of the original owner and become functionally obsellete quicker. They also tend to be more expensive and that in and of itself is detrimental to a higher appreciation rate. Its all about location. Beach houses appreciated more and happen to be mostly custom builds. If they threw tracts on oceanfront lots in the 60’s and 70’s you would see higher appreciation also

[sdrealtor]

My experience has been that custom homes dont necessarily hold value better. They tend to be built more specific to the desires of the original owner and become functionally obsellete quicker. They also tend to be more expensive and that in and of itself is detrimental to a higher appreciation rate. Its all about location. Beach houses appreciated more and happen to be mostly custom builds. If they threw tracts on oceanfront lots in the 60’s and 70’s you would see higher appreciation also

[jstoesz]

Thankfully, I think you are right!

Everyone, buy track homes, they are awesome. Galley kitchens and wood paneling suck. Only termites and whores like custom homes. Did I mention the amphetamines (but I digress)!

[jstoesz]

Thankfully, I think you are right!

Everyone, buy track homes, they are awesome. Galley kitchens and wood paneling suck. Only termites and whores like custom homes. Did I mention the amphetamines (but I digress)!

[jstoesz]

Thankfully, I think you are right!

Everyone, buy track homes, they are awesome. Galley kitchens and wood paneling suck. Only termites and whores like custom homes. Did I mention the amphetamines (but I digress)!

[jstoesz]

Thankfully, I think you are right!

Everyone, buy track homes, they are awesome. Galley kitchens and wood paneling suck. Only termites and whores like custom homes. Did I mention the amphetamines (but I digress)!

[jstoesz]

Thankfully, I think you are right!

Everyone, buy track homes, they are awesome. Galley kitchens and wood paneling suck. Only termites and whores like custom homes. Did I mention the amphetamines (but I digress)!

[an]

[quote=sdrealtor]My experience has been that custom homes dont necessarily hold value better. They tend to be built more specific to the desires of the original owner and become functionally obsellete quicker. They also tend to be more expensive and that in and of itself is detrimental to a higher appreciation rate. Its all about location. Beach houses appreciated more and happen to be mostly custom builds. If they threw tracts on oceanfront lots in the 60’s and 70’s you would see higher appreciation also[/quote]
That’s my assumption as well, but I don’t have data to back up my assumption. At the end of the day, it’s all about location location location. With that said, based on your experience, what make a location ideal? proximity to the beach, jobs, entertainment, etc? Do you think older areas appreciate more as well because it’s built out? Supply/demand?

[an]

[quote=sdrealtor]My experience has been that custom homes dont necessarily hold value better. They tend to be built more specific to the desires of the original owner and become functionally obsellete quicker. They also tend to be more expensive and that in and of itself is detrimental to a higher appreciation rate. Its all about location. Beach houses appreciated more and happen to be mostly custom builds. If they threw tracts on oceanfront lots in the 60’s and 70’s you would see higher appreciation also[/quote]
That’s my assumption as well, but I don’t have data to back up my assumption. At the end of the day, it’s all about location location location. With that said, based on your experience, what make a location ideal? proximity to the beach, jobs, entertainment, etc? Do you think older areas appreciate more as well because it’s built out? Supply/demand?

[an]

[quote=sdrealtor]My experience has been that custom homes dont necessarily hold value better. They tend to be built more specific to the desires of the original owner and become functionally obsellete quicker. They also tend to be more expensive and that in and of itself is detrimental to a higher appreciation rate. Its all about location. Beach houses appreciated more and happen to be mostly custom builds. If they threw tracts on oceanfront lots in the 60’s and 70’s you would see higher appreciation also[/quote]
That’s my assumption as well, but I don’t have data to back up my assumption. At the end of the day, it’s all about location location location. With that said, based on your experience, what make a location ideal? proximity to the beach, jobs, entertainment, etc? Do you think older areas appreciate more as well because it’s built out? Supply/demand?

[an]

[quote=sdrealtor]My experience has been that custom homes dont necessarily hold value better. They tend to be built more specific to the desires of the original owner and become functionally obsellete quicker. They also tend to be more expensive and that in and of itself is detrimental to a higher appreciation rate. Its all about location. Beach houses appreciated more and happen to be mostly custom builds. If they threw tracts on oceanfront lots in the 60’s and 70’s you would see higher appreciation also[/quote]
That’s my assumption as well, but I don’t have data to back up my assumption. At the end of the day, it’s all about location location location. With that said, based on your experience, what make a location ideal? proximity to the beach, jobs, entertainment, etc? Do you think older areas appreciate more as well because it’s built out? Supply/demand?

[Author]

Posts