Home › Forums › Financial Markets/Economics › Car, lease or buy?
- This topic has 177 replies, 19 voices, and was last updated 13 years, 2 months ago by earlyretirement.
-
AuthorPosts
-
December 18, 2007 at 11:30 AM #119970December 18, 2007 at 11:36 AM #119743Diego MamaniParticipant
From a financial point of view, I’d get a used Lexus, Accura, Toyota, or Honda, and pay cash for it.
But car purchases can be emotional and few of us can be rational. In 2001 I bought a brand new Mustang, mostly because I liked its shape. I thought (or “knew”) that a Toyota, even a used one, may have been more reliable.
My car was a newspaper ad special at $14.9K (a V6) and it came with 0% APR for 60 months. I put only $500 down (!) I made my last payment over a year ago, the car now has only 52K miles, and looks/runs like new. Never any problems. I do take care of it, though.
A similar story with my wife’s Subaru. Both cars are paid in full, and they are well maintained. No thanks, no car payments for me!
December 18, 2007 at 11:36 AM #119879Diego MamaniParticipantFrom a financial point of view, I’d get a used Lexus, Accura, Toyota, or Honda, and pay cash for it.
But car purchases can be emotional and few of us can be rational. In 2001 I bought a brand new Mustang, mostly because I liked its shape. I thought (or “knew”) that a Toyota, even a used one, may have been more reliable.
My car was a newspaper ad special at $14.9K (a V6) and it came with 0% APR for 60 months. I put only $500 down (!) I made my last payment over a year ago, the car now has only 52K miles, and looks/runs like new. Never any problems. I do take care of it, though.
A similar story with my wife’s Subaru. Both cars are paid in full, and they are well maintained. No thanks, no car payments for me!
December 18, 2007 at 11:36 AM #119910Diego MamaniParticipantFrom a financial point of view, I’d get a used Lexus, Accura, Toyota, or Honda, and pay cash for it.
But car purchases can be emotional and few of us can be rational. In 2001 I bought a brand new Mustang, mostly because I liked its shape. I thought (or “knew”) that a Toyota, even a used one, may have been more reliable.
My car was a newspaper ad special at $14.9K (a V6) and it came with 0% APR for 60 months. I put only $500 down (!) I made my last payment over a year ago, the car now has only 52K miles, and looks/runs like new. Never any problems. I do take care of it, though.
A similar story with my wife’s Subaru. Both cars are paid in full, and they are well maintained. No thanks, no car payments for me!
December 18, 2007 at 11:36 AM #119957Diego MamaniParticipantFrom a financial point of view, I’d get a used Lexus, Accura, Toyota, or Honda, and pay cash for it.
But car purchases can be emotional and few of us can be rational. In 2001 I bought a brand new Mustang, mostly because I liked its shape. I thought (or “knew”) that a Toyota, even a used one, may have been more reliable.
My car was a newspaper ad special at $14.9K (a V6) and it came with 0% APR for 60 months. I put only $500 down (!) I made my last payment over a year ago, the car now has only 52K miles, and looks/runs like new. Never any problems. I do take care of it, though.
A similar story with my wife’s Subaru. Both cars are paid in full, and they are well maintained. No thanks, no car payments for me!
December 18, 2007 at 11:36 AM #119975Diego MamaniParticipantFrom a financial point of view, I’d get a used Lexus, Accura, Toyota, or Honda, and pay cash for it.
But car purchases can be emotional and few of us can be rational. In 2001 I bought a brand new Mustang, mostly because I liked its shape. I thought (or “knew”) that a Toyota, even a used one, may have been more reliable.
My car was a newspaper ad special at $14.9K (a V6) and it came with 0% APR for 60 months. I put only $500 down (!) I made my last payment over a year ago, the car now has only 52K miles, and looks/runs like new. Never any problems. I do take care of it, though.
A similar story with my wife’s Subaru. Both cars are paid in full, and they are well maintained. No thanks, no car payments for me!
December 18, 2007 at 11:51 AM #119758DaCounselorParticipantBe sure to investigate and compare insurance costs for a leased car versus a used car. Leases often require substantial amounts of coverage that go beyond what you may normally select, and any extra costs should be factored in your analysis.
I will say, for whatever it’s worth, that I have been lured to at least consider leasing by the thought of driving a new luxury car every few years. However, after crunching the numbers I always come back down to earth and end up purchasing a late model used (uh, excuse me, I mean “pre-owned”) car. I can say that over the past 12 years I have saved a large sum of money by going used while still driving excellent cars.
December 18, 2007 at 11:51 AM #119894DaCounselorParticipantBe sure to investigate and compare insurance costs for a leased car versus a used car. Leases often require substantial amounts of coverage that go beyond what you may normally select, and any extra costs should be factored in your analysis.
I will say, for whatever it’s worth, that I have been lured to at least consider leasing by the thought of driving a new luxury car every few years. However, after crunching the numbers I always come back down to earth and end up purchasing a late model used (uh, excuse me, I mean “pre-owned”) car. I can say that over the past 12 years I have saved a large sum of money by going used while still driving excellent cars.
December 18, 2007 at 11:51 AM #119925DaCounselorParticipantBe sure to investigate and compare insurance costs for a leased car versus a used car. Leases often require substantial amounts of coverage that go beyond what you may normally select, and any extra costs should be factored in your analysis.
I will say, for whatever it’s worth, that I have been lured to at least consider leasing by the thought of driving a new luxury car every few years. However, after crunching the numbers I always come back down to earth and end up purchasing a late model used (uh, excuse me, I mean “pre-owned”) car. I can say that over the past 12 years I have saved a large sum of money by going used while still driving excellent cars.
December 18, 2007 at 11:51 AM #119972DaCounselorParticipantBe sure to investigate and compare insurance costs for a leased car versus a used car. Leases often require substantial amounts of coverage that go beyond what you may normally select, and any extra costs should be factored in your analysis.
I will say, for whatever it’s worth, that I have been lured to at least consider leasing by the thought of driving a new luxury car every few years. However, after crunching the numbers I always come back down to earth and end up purchasing a late model used (uh, excuse me, I mean “pre-owned”) car. I can say that over the past 12 years I have saved a large sum of money by going used while still driving excellent cars.
December 18, 2007 at 11:51 AM #119990DaCounselorParticipantBe sure to investigate and compare insurance costs for a leased car versus a used car. Leases often require substantial amounts of coverage that go beyond what you may normally select, and any extra costs should be factored in your analysis.
I will say, for whatever it’s worth, that I have been lured to at least consider leasing by the thought of driving a new luxury car every few years. However, after crunching the numbers I always come back down to earth and end up purchasing a late model used (uh, excuse me, I mean “pre-owned”) car. I can say that over the past 12 years I have saved a large sum of money by going used while still driving excellent cars.
December 18, 2007 at 12:20 PM #119773cooperthedogParticipantCars are depreciating assets.
I’ve noticed that used car lots are full of high-end cars vs. a few years ago, and I would expect prices to fall further as people who can’t afford those cars start returning them, credit dries up, etc.
As for a new car purchase or lease, I would let someone else take the bulk of the depreciation (i.e. buy a used car that is at least a few years old). I’ve never leased a car, but I’m pretty sure the dealership will structure it so you pay all the depreciation (and then some).
It sounds like you are well ahead of the game w/ 100k saved at 24 years old. Why not focus on adding to that and growing it, while keeping your current (paid) car?
With that said, when I was in my twenties I purchased a Porsche, and later on an M3 (both slightly used of course), which weren’t the best financial decisions in hindsight, but boy did I have a good time… You have to balance life now with fiscal responsibility.
It appears that you want something speedy, so I’d recommend buying a luxury/sports car that is older (late 90’s) from an original or 2nd owner, who is older (well maintained & not abused). You could pickup a nice BMW or some such for ~12k. In fact, you could drive it for a two years, throw it away, and buy another and do the same thing and end up the same financially as leasing the new car…
December 18, 2007 at 12:20 PM #119909cooperthedogParticipantCars are depreciating assets.
I’ve noticed that used car lots are full of high-end cars vs. a few years ago, and I would expect prices to fall further as people who can’t afford those cars start returning them, credit dries up, etc.
As for a new car purchase or lease, I would let someone else take the bulk of the depreciation (i.e. buy a used car that is at least a few years old). I’ve never leased a car, but I’m pretty sure the dealership will structure it so you pay all the depreciation (and then some).
It sounds like you are well ahead of the game w/ 100k saved at 24 years old. Why not focus on adding to that and growing it, while keeping your current (paid) car?
With that said, when I was in my twenties I purchased a Porsche, and later on an M3 (both slightly used of course), which weren’t the best financial decisions in hindsight, but boy did I have a good time… You have to balance life now with fiscal responsibility.
It appears that you want something speedy, so I’d recommend buying a luxury/sports car that is older (late 90’s) from an original or 2nd owner, who is older (well maintained & not abused). You could pickup a nice BMW or some such for ~12k. In fact, you could drive it for a two years, throw it away, and buy another and do the same thing and end up the same financially as leasing the new car…
December 18, 2007 at 12:20 PM #119940cooperthedogParticipantCars are depreciating assets.
I’ve noticed that used car lots are full of high-end cars vs. a few years ago, and I would expect prices to fall further as people who can’t afford those cars start returning them, credit dries up, etc.
As for a new car purchase or lease, I would let someone else take the bulk of the depreciation (i.e. buy a used car that is at least a few years old). I’ve never leased a car, but I’m pretty sure the dealership will structure it so you pay all the depreciation (and then some).
It sounds like you are well ahead of the game w/ 100k saved at 24 years old. Why not focus on adding to that and growing it, while keeping your current (paid) car?
With that said, when I was in my twenties I purchased a Porsche, and later on an M3 (both slightly used of course), which weren’t the best financial decisions in hindsight, but boy did I have a good time… You have to balance life now with fiscal responsibility.
It appears that you want something speedy, so I’d recommend buying a luxury/sports car that is older (late 90’s) from an original or 2nd owner, who is older (well maintained & not abused). You could pickup a nice BMW or some such for ~12k. In fact, you could drive it for a two years, throw it away, and buy another and do the same thing and end up the same financially as leasing the new car…
December 18, 2007 at 12:20 PM #119987cooperthedogParticipantCars are depreciating assets.
I’ve noticed that used car lots are full of high-end cars vs. a few years ago, and I would expect prices to fall further as people who can’t afford those cars start returning them, credit dries up, etc.
As for a new car purchase or lease, I would let someone else take the bulk of the depreciation (i.e. buy a used car that is at least a few years old). I’ve never leased a car, but I’m pretty sure the dealership will structure it so you pay all the depreciation (and then some).
It sounds like you are well ahead of the game w/ 100k saved at 24 years old. Why not focus on adding to that and growing it, while keeping your current (paid) car?
With that said, when I was in my twenties I purchased a Porsche, and later on an M3 (both slightly used of course), which weren’t the best financial decisions in hindsight, but boy did I have a good time… You have to balance life now with fiscal responsibility.
It appears that you want something speedy, so I’d recommend buying a luxury/sports car that is older (late 90’s) from an original or 2nd owner, who is older (well maintained & not abused). You could pickup a nice BMW or some such for ~12k. In fact, you could drive it for a two years, throw it away, and buy another and do the same thing and end up the same financially as leasing the new car…
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.