“Zillow” is “delusional” in that it uses a “one size fits all” valuation and does not account for individual property improvements OR the differing ways property is appraised in the various regions of the country.
“Zillow” simply valuates all properties by sq footage as if they were situated on a homogenous tract with limited models/floor plans.
I take “Zillow” with a grain of salt.
Edit: Over three of your $125K-comps will fit inside the Paul residence, lol ….