Agreed, Craigslist works great if your price is at or below market. Rents likely have dropped in your area, so rather than try to rent it for what it’s gotten in the past, check current rates and price just below them. I have a few friends who are convinced their rentals are the best in the neighborhood, they set their price higher without budging, then are forced to take in questionable tenants because they’ll pay more. Three months later they wonder why they have an eviction on their hands and thousands of dollars in repairs. I guess in their minds, the extra $100/month was worth it?