[quote=sdrealtor]If your house is smaller than the recent comps it could very well be in line with them. Your agent is correct that $/sq ft falls as the house gets bigger. How big is your house relative to the recent comps?[/quote]

The house is a little over 1500. The comps are 240 and 320 more sq feet, respectively. After my post, my wife reminded me that we looked at a newer but smaller house nearby that went for $260 per square foot. But it’s also 16 years newer, so maybe that’s why our agent didn’t include it.