[quote=spdrun]Tile. Fiberglass just feels cheap and oogy.

Here’s an idea, though. If you’re re-doing the bathroom, build a sealed pan with a slight lip at the entry door, and a slight drop towards the shower, and the drain at the lowest point. Tile over the sealed pan. No need for a shower stall at all, though you can keep glass walls for effect.

Shower stalls are an outdated idea in my book.[/quote]
What you’re describing is a “wet room”… or accessible shower.
(We put that in for our ADA compliant granny flat since my father in law is in a wheelchair…)
Good shower curtain (or frameless glass) is necessary to keep the toilet paper dry. 🙂