We like the guys at Carmel Valley Collision Center (http://www.carmelvalleycollision.com/) on Sorrento Valley Rd. Unfortunately, having teenagers, we’ve had to use their services twice and they’ve always provided us with a very fair price and done a perfect job.
I’ve also heard good things about Amato’s but a friend who used them thought they were expensive, and when they worked on her car, they somehow screwed up the electronic locking system, which prevented her from locking her car…she picked it up on a Friday and couldn’t bring it back until Mon because they were closed so she spent the weekend being a little nervous about leaving her (very expensive) car unlocked wherever she went.