OT: Why Miramar Ranch is low in API score when compared to other Scripps Ranch elementary schools

User Forum Topic
Submitted by g2006 on June 13, 2012 - 8:32pm

We are trying to buy a home in Scripps Ranch and the elementary school is Miramar Ranch. When I compare the API score it looks Miramar Ranch is the lowest in Scripps Ranch (compared to Dingeman..etc).

Any idea why Miramar Ranch is low in API score when compared to other Scripps Ranch elementary schools

Appreciate any comments.

Thanks

Submitted by ocrenter on June 14, 2012 - 7:31am.

Miramar Ranch and Jerabeck are both in the low 900 range while EBS and Dingeman are in the high 900 range.

Has more to do with location. EBS and Dingeman are drawing from newer homes with average price of 800k and up. Whereas MR and Jerabeck draw from mostly older homes starting in 600k and up, along with mix of condos. Prob more renters in that mix as well, since older homes are more likely to be rented vs newer homes.

Is there really that much hair to split comparing elementary API of 990 vs 920?

But then again, CV parents have sleepless nights because they can't get into Ocean Air and have to suffer the wreth of Sage Canyon.

Submitted by flu on June 14, 2012 - 7:40am.

ocrenter wrote:
Miramar Ranch and Jerabeck are both in the low 900 range while EBS and Dingeman are in the high 900 range.

Has more to do with location. EBS and Dingeman are drawing from newer homes with average price of 800k and up. Whereas MR and Jerabeck draw from mostly older homes starting in 600k and up, along with mix of condos. Prob more renters in that mix as well, since older homes are more likely to be rented vs newer homes.

Is there really that much hair to split comparing elementary API of 990 vs 920?

But then again, CV parents have sleepless nights because they can't get into Ocean Air and have to suffer the wreth of Sage Canyon.

No you got it wrong....Underprivileged kids with parents that can't afford to live in a home with access to sage canyon OR ocean air end up having to live in the slums of Carmel Valley and are forced to send their kids to ghetto schools like Torrey Hills or Ashley Falls or Sycamore Ridge or Del Mar Heights School or Carmel Del Mar School with the low low low test scores of nine forty-osh plus or minus twenty and live off of food stamps.

Submitted by poorgradstudent on June 14, 2012 - 9:00am.

ocrenter wrote:
Is there really that much hair to split comparing elementary API of 990 vs 920?

Like IQ scores, API becomes fairly worthless after it goes above a certain level. But then again, I view API as fairly worthless to begin with as a measure of anything but the wealth of people living in the area, so I'm not sure I'd trust my opinion.

Submitted by Rhett on June 14, 2012 - 3:42pm.

Be very careful when comparing API scores. Though there might be a lot of validity in the reasons already given for the differing API scores - number of English learners, students with disabilities, etc. (though in the case of Scripps Ranch, the school with the highest test score had the most reported English learners - hmmm...).

Related to this, the 2011 API scores just came out.

http://dq.cde.ca.gov/dataquest/Acnt2012/...

Submitted by AN on June 14, 2012 - 8:28pm.

API only tell you what the demographic of the student body is. One shouldn't read too much into it to determine how well your kid(s) will perform. That's up to your kid(s), you, and their teachers.

Submitted by ScrippsTrailRider on August 20, 2012 - 10:08am.

The answer is the demographics. EBS has a higher Asian population than the other two schools. Asian parents, particularly Chinese, Koreans and Indians are pushing their kids extremely hard - some say too hard - to get good grades. Incidentally, a school's API score, especially in this range has very little to do with how well any one particular individual will do in school. Academics is not a team sport.

Submitted by flu on August 20, 2012 - 11:20am.

ScrippsTrailRider wrote:
The answer is the demographics. EBS has a higher Asian population than the other two schools. Asian parents, particularly Chinese, Koreans and Indians are pushing their kids extremely hard - some say too hard - to get good grades. Incidentally, a school's API score, especially in this range has very little to do with how well any one particular individual will do in school. Academics is not a team sport.

Ah yes, it's always the asians that are screwing everyone else up...Now I understand why a lot of younger generations these days have the victim/entitlement mentality...kids are screwed up, obviously from retarded parents..

Submitted by SD Realtor on August 20, 2012 - 12:44pm.

Damn FLU you figured it out.

Quit pushing your child to do well. You are screwing it up for the rest of us!!!

Soon you will be asked to distribute the intelligence.

Submitted by flyer on August 20, 2012 - 3:46pm.

Shhhh--Don't tell people API scores will ultimately have very little to do with how successful one's children become--that's one way we're keeping property values and rents inflated in said areas.

But, seriously, my kids, and most of their friends, were raised in RSF, and went to great schools, yet the LIFE success rate of these kids--from what we've seen now that they are grown--still seems to be about 50/50--if that.

Probably evidence that achieving one's "dream life" has many elements--many of which are out of our control.

So, my point to the OP--If the API scores of the two schools you are comparing are fairly close, I wouldn't worry about it too much.

Submitted by desmond on August 20, 2012 - 4:01pm.

flu wrote:
Ah yes, it's always the asians that are screwing everyone else up...Now I understand why a lot of younger generations these days have the victim/entitlement mentality...kids are screwed up, obviously from retarded parents..

Don't forget the renters, you left out the renters......the lowlife renters...........

Submitted by ocrenter on August 20, 2012 - 7:28pm.

SD Realtor wrote:
Damn FLU you figured it out.

Quit pushing your child to do well. You are screwing it up for the rest of us!!!

Soon you will be asked to distribute the intelligence.

already done, it's called affirmative action

Submitted by squat300 on August 20, 2012 - 9:29pm.

waht does determine life success????

some balanced combination of empathy and ego....with a spark of wanting something...

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.